• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Traded in my Genny

tarche

Getting familiar with the group...
Joined
Jul 29, 2010
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
NW Philly Suburbs
After two years, I decided to call it quits on my 2010 Genny. I've struggled with the jittery ride since day 3 and tried to make the best of it ever since, but a health scare a month ago reinforced that life is too short. I also disliked the engine braking on the ZF transmission that was very pronounced between 32 and 25 while decelerating. There is another thread on that right now and I agree with those who find that the car does not coast the way you expect when taking your foot off the gas. The overall ride just seemed wrong to me, kinda like a super hot girl who gets out on the dance floor and looks awkward.

With that said, I'm certainly going to miss the Lexicon, which is by far the best car stereo I've heard. I'll also miss the awesome acceleration and passing power of the V8. For the money it's a great car, loaded with features, looks great in a parking lot, but the ride just didn't suit my taste. Others who've driven my car liked it just fine, but in the end I had to go in a different direction.

As far as problems go, it was relatively trouble free, aside from a fuel pump failure, a propeller shaft replacement (tsb), and cupping Dunlops that had to be replaced at only 13K miles. I had the stereo go silent on me only twice and each time it was fine after the next restart of the car.

I replaced it with a 2013 Subaru Outback Limited -- obviously an entirely different car. I was also considering the 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid. My logic was that since I'd be taking such a financial hit trading a car after only two years, I wanted to get a desireable feature, in this case AWD or hybrid gas mileage. The Subaru won out because the dealer offered me the better deal, including 25K for my Genny. Unlike my Genny test drive, I test drove each car three seperate times over roads on my daily commute and around my area so I know I have a car that provides a comfortable ride over familiar territory. The Subaru has a surprisingly good stereo although it's no Lexicon. It does however has perfect iPod integration (including album art) which is a welcome change. I got it fully loaded so the feature set is not dramatically different, but it has over 200 fewer horsepower which is quite a difference, but the 2.5i engine seems sprightly enough for me. The CVT transmission is also quiet and smooth. All in all, I'm pretty happy.

Best of luck to all of you with your Genny's. It sounds like the stiff suspension moved towards my softer taste in 2012 and someday I may be back if they continue to provide so much car for the money as they make subsequent model year improvements.

--Tom
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
My wife is looking to replace her Infiniti G35 coupe (which can't comfortably accomodate child safety seats) with a grandbaby hauler (an evenuality, by the way, that's not likely to happen more than once every blue moon - she's never once been asked to drive a grandchild anywhere). She's looked at Volvo XC60 and Acura RDX. I tried mightily to get her to consider the Outback, which I think is a much smarter buy, but she won't look at it, unfortunately. Hope you enjoy yours!
 
Best wishes with your new car, may it provide you many years of happy trails :)....until we meet again ...ok yes ! I went there lol. :grouphug:
 
+10

After two years, I decided to call it quits on my 2010 Genny. I've struggled with the jittery ride since day 3 and tried to make the best of it ever since, but a health scare a month ago reinforced that life is too short. I also disliked the engine braking on the ZF transmission that was very pronounced between 32 and 25 while decelerating. There is another thread on that right now and I agree with those who find that the car does not coast the way you expect when taking your foot off the gas. The overall ride just seemed wrong to me, kinda like a super hot girl who gets out on the dance floor and looks awkward.

With that said, I'm certainly going to miss the Lexicon, which is by far the best car stereo I've heard. I'll also miss the awesome acceleration and passing power of the V8. For the money it's a great car, loaded with features, looks great in a parking lot, but the ride just didn't suit my taste. Others who've driven my car liked it just fine, but in the end I had to go in a different direction.

As far as problems go, it was relatively trouble free, aside from a fuel pump failure, a propeller shaft replacement (tsb), and cupping Dunlops that had to be replaced at only 13K miles. I had the stereo go silent on me only twice and each time it was fine after the next restart of the car.

I replaced it with a 2013 Subaru Outback Limited -- obviously an entirely different car. I was also considering the 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid. My logic was that since I'd be taking such a financial hit trading a car after only two years, I wanted to get a desireable feature, in this case AWD or hybrid gas mileage. The Subaru won out because the dealer offered me the better deal, including 25K for my Genny. Unlike my Genny test drive, I test drove each car three seperate times over roads on my daily commute and around my area so I know I have a car that provides a comfortable ride over familiar territory. The Subaru has a surprisingly good stereo although it's no Lexicon. It does however has perfect iPod integration (including album art) which is a welcome change. I got it fully loaded so the feature set is not dramatically different, but it has over 200 fewer horsepower which is quite a difference, but the 2.5i engine seems sprightly enough for me. The CVT transmission is also quiet and smooth. All in all, I'm pretty happy.

Best of luck to all of you with your Genny's. It sounds like the stiff suspension moved towards my softer taste in 2012 and someday I may be back if they continue to provide so much car for the money as they make subsequent model year improvements.

--Tom
 
So this is the biggest complaint I hear about the Genesis... jittery, busy, unsettling ride. What exactly is the problem? Does the car sway from side to side in its lane requiring constant adjustments from driver? Does the steering wheel shake? Does this problem only happen at highway speeds?

Please explain
 
So this is the biggest complaint I hear about the Genesis... jittery, busy, unsettling ride. What exactly is the problem? Does the car sway from side to side in its lane requiring constant adjustments from driver? Does the steering wheel shake? Does this problem only happen at highway speeds?

Please explain

No such problems with 2012 MY, IMHO.
 
Bye Tom.... see you in 2014'ish.

;)
 
Congrats Tom. I had a health scare recently so I understand and it's great you cut bait and got what you wanted. I traded my 2009 genny for a 2012 genny after hating the ride for almost 3 years. The '12 ride is completely different. I smile every day I drive to work.
 
By the way, the Outback is a sweet car. My father has one. As a matter of fact, this is his second one, and it's loaded with goodies. Good luck!
 
My 2 previous cars to the Ginny were Subaru and they are great cars. Both were very reliable. My problem with the Subaru only came up after a long days drive I would be wore out from the seats. A full day in the Ginny and I'm still feeling fine. Most comfortable seats in any car I've ever had. I have a 2011 Ginny and have never noticed any of the drivehandling problems you had.
______________________________

Help support this site so it can continue supporting you!
 
Subaru's are awesome rides, as I have owned a Legacy and my dad still owns his 2002 Outback. My brother has a Legacy GT limited 5MT. All have been great and reliable (except for the well known head gasket issue on the Outback).

I'd love to own another Subie, but they keep getting worse looking (except outback), but they have for now lost my business due to being so freaking outdated. Still using 5 speed trannys, or even worse now CVT's and their engines do not make a lot of power and they use a lot of fuel due to the AWD compared to other vehicles of same class. If they made a Legacy with at very least 300hp and it returned decent mpg's I'd consider again. My 4.6L Genesis get a little better mileage than my brothers Legacy, and that car is very light compared to the Genesis and it has 125 less HP.
 
Back
Top