With all the glowing reviews I've read about the new GS 350, I finally stopped by my local Lexus dealer for a test drive. The car had the same setup that car mags have been driving, ie with the F sport package. I drove it at the standard setting, and at the Sport + setting.
Advantages over the Genesis 4.6:
1. GS is smaller, lighter, and hence felt more nimble.
2. GS being a redesign, had a nicer interior. Loved the 12 inch LCD screen.
3. GS with the Sport + setting had slightly firmer suspension, and leaned less than the Genny during cornering.
Disadvantages:
1. GS engine did not sound as good as the 4.6 Tau. The Lexus salesman actually opened up the hood to show me this sound generator. It's basically a speaker that amplifies the intake noise. I was totally surprised that the noise was not very pleasant as it had a raspy quality to it. You don't hear it with light throttle application, but under moderate to heavy throttle, you definitely hear it. I much prefer the quiet growl of the Tau engine.
2. GS did not feel any faster than the Genny in regard to acceleration. I think official 0-60 times are about the same also.
3. GS cabin is not as roomy.
4. GS is priced $50+. With similar equipment levels, it's 15k-20k more than the Genny.
Other considerations:
Both cars seemed equally quiet in regard to road noise and wind noise.
The GS styling is not that weird in person.
In the end, I felt that I liked my V8 Genny more, mainly because of the wonderfully smooth motor. However, I wish the next generation Genesis will add the feature that Lexus attempted but failed miserably on:
add a sound generator or tube that goes into the cabin, but make sure that the sound is good (no raspy tones please), and that it's defeatable with a switch. I would be willing to pay $1000 just for that.
Advantages over the Genesis 4.6:
1. GS is smaller, lighter, and hence felt more nimble.
2. GS being a redesign, had a nicer interior. Loved the 12 inch LCD screen.
3. GS with the Sport + setting had slightly firmer suspension, and leaned less than the Genny during cornering.
Disadvantages:
1. GS engine did not sound as good as the 4.6 Tau. The Lexus salesman actually opened up the hood to show me this sound generator. It's basically a speaker that amplifies the intake noise. I was totally surprised that the noise was not very pleasant as it had a raspy quality to it. You don't hear it with light throttle application, but under moderate to heavy throttle, you definitely hear it. I much prefer the quiet growl of the Tau engine.
2. GS did not feel any faster than the Genny in regard to acceleration. I think official 0-60 times are about the same also.
3. GS cabin is not as roomy.
4. GS is priced $50+. With similar equipment levels, it's 15k-20k more than the Genny.
Other considerations:
Both cars seemed equally quiet in regard to road noise and wind noise.
The GS styling is not that weird in person.
In the end, I felt that I liked my V8 Genny more, mainly because of the wonderfully smooth motor. However, I wish the next generation Genesis will add the feature that Lexus attempted but failed miserably on:
add a sound generator or tube that goes into the cabin, but make sure that the sound is good (no raspy tones please), and that it's defeatable with a switch. I would be willing to pay $1000 just for that.