• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Genesis "dealer" profits are higher than Porsche, due to lack of independent showrooms

Backslack

Registered Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2020
Messages
1,773
Reaction score
1,093
Points
113
From a recent interview with the chairman of the Genesis National Dealer Advisory Council, who is also the owner of Genesis of Cherry Hill in Marlton, N.J:

For a lot of dealers I talk to, and even for us, our Genesis business is our most profitable brand in terms of return on sales. It's very efficient. Part of that is because it's sharing space in the Hyundai facility. So, it doesn't yet have the full expense structure that it will have the day it moves into its exclusive facility.
Genesis profitability is at all-time record levels. Our return on sales for Genesis is probably where Porsche and Mercedes-Benz have aspired to over the years.

It's no wonder the independent Hyundai dealerships are so adamant about not building standalone showrooms for Genesis when they can rake in profits that exceed Porsche with the current setup.
 
Last edited:
Full interview here for those who are paywalled:

Genesis dealers: New EVs boosting sales​


Genesis tripled sales last year to 49,621 on the strength of its new GV70 and GV80 crossovers. The Korean upstart was named the best premium nameplate in the J.D. Power dependability study. And after years of struggling with U.S. distribution out of Hyundai dealerships, it's heading down an independent path.
"Genesis' time is here, and it seems to be getting all of the needed support that the Genesis dealers could really hope for," said Peter Lanzavecchia, 66, chairman of the Genesis National Dealer Advisory Council and owner of Genesis of Cherry Hill in Marlton, N.J.
Parent company Hyundai Motor Group prioritized the young brand during its growth spurt over the past 16 months, when Genesis finally had the vehicles and marketing to reach the next level. Last year's sales were just 8,932 shy of Infiniti, which is three decades old compared with just 6 years old for Genesis.
While Lanzavecchia doesn't expect the same level of growth this year, he does expect upwards of 20 percent as Hyundai Motor Group continues to give its premium brand priority for semiconductor chips. Genesis will also launch its first two electric vehicles this year, the GV60 and Electrified G80.
Lanzavecchia spoke with Staff Reporter Laurence Iliff. Here are edited excerpts.
Q: Genesis is growing fast, with hot new vehicles that many U.S. consumers are just learning about. Are you concerned that the aggressive pivot to EVs will confuse buyers just getting to know Genesis' internal-combustion vehicles?
A:
No, not at all. Actually, we have seen a tremendous increase in the brand's recognition and awareness. And that leads to higher levels of consideration. In 2021, I think that was partly due to [COO] Claudia Marquez's update to our Tier 1 advertising strategy and funding. That really seemed to come on strong in the fourth quarter. Every brand, certainly every premium brand, has announced the transition to EV, so we are looking forward to Genesis continuing its leadership in design and tech and safety with our EV entries as we transition away from ICE models. We're not concerned. We're thrilled with the level of acceptance and desire for our models, and we think we'll see the same or even greater demand for our EV models once they're launched.
Genesis will soon have its first EVs with the GV60 and the Electrified G80, which are potential competitors for the Tesla Model Y and Model S. How do you see that competition?
New Jersey, I think, has four Tesla retail locations and one of them is in Cherry Hill. They do very well. We see shoppers from time to time looking at Genesis while also shopping Tesla. We've had more than a handful of trade-ins from Teslas. There's a little bit of concern in the Tesla owner community with the service. Where to go for service if they don't live near a Tesla location. We welcome the competition. Tesla is a great car, great brand. They've done a great job paving the way, really by creating the charging infrastructure.
Has Genesis developed a road map that will guide dealers during the EV transition?
For sure. The retailers have been given the road map, the announcement, that there will be no new ICE launches after 2025 and no new ICE production after 2030. Our whole industry has committed to eliminating tailpipe emissions. So every OEM, of course, is now trying to fast track. It seems like whatever announcements were made six months ago about BEV investments are being increased in terms of both timing and financial commitment.
How do dealers feel about the transition timeline?
We've seen in Hyundai Motor Group's Strategy 2025 document that electrification is a massive priority for the parent company for all the brands, and we're very excited about how we are going to prepare for EVs.
All of the dealers have been given the blueprint not only for the charging infrastructure that dealers will require as they build their Genesis exclusive facilities, but we've been given a future-proof document and design of how to expand that EV charging infrastructure both inside the facility and on the property as we transition more models post-2025.
Do you think dealers would like to see hybrids as a transition, even though Genesis has committed to going straight from ICE to full EVs?
No, I think dealers are ready for BEVs. We're seeing a lot of acceptance for plug-in hybrids on our Hyundai side and I think you'll see continued leadership on those from the Hyundai brand. But where we're going with Genesis in the premium segments is full battery-electric vehicles. And of course, there is the whole specter of hydrogen that's looming out there, but the charging structure for that is much further behind that for electric vehicles. So, it looks like the big push for us will be into 100 percent EV. Government incentives and mandates have a lot to do with the speed and the acceptance from the buying public short-term until the costs become more at parity [with ICE]. But currently, we are anticipating a very high level of demand for our first electric sport-utility, the GV60.
Prior to the end of Genesis ICE launches in 2025, what would dealers like to see on the internal-combustion side?
As you know, we started Genesis with a sedan and then more sedans — the G70, G80, G90. With the introduction of our SUVs, we've kind of got the sweet spot of both the sedan and the SUV segments covered now. We're in the highest volume segments.
I hear industry analysts say that a GV90 large crossover is a logical one. What do dealers want?
There has been some talk of a GV90, and I think dealers would be happy to get an additional, larger SUV. But if you look over at BMW, I don't know if their X7 volume is really that meaningful compared to X5 and X3. So, we're right where we want to be in terms of the highest-volume offerings. And we think the redesigned G90 sedan, which is out this year, is really going to establish that model as our true flagship. We've all seen the early reviews on that vehicle and it really is a true game-changer in that large premium sedan segment.
What's the latest update on the Keystone facility program and the construction of standalone Genesis stores?
I think you and I have talked about this for three years now, and probably even as recently as last year there was still some concern out there in the retail network about the Keystone program. There's no question at this point as we sit here today that [separate] exclusive stores for Genesis and Hyundai is really the only way dealers are going to maximize success with those two brands.
What are the next steps in the Keystone process?
There's really two pieces: the dealer network topic and the facility topic, and they are certainly interrelated. The Genesis Motor America leadership team and the retail advisory board are in total alignment on reducing the current size of the retailer network. The difficult part becomes in executing that. It's actually beginning to pick up some momentum. There were more voluntary terminations in the fourth quarter than there had been prior. And we're coming up on some deadlines.
What about separating Hyundai stores from Genesis sales?
We're currently in a grace period where cohabitation with Genesis is permitted, but that will expire. And that will really force the issue for many retailers to find a location to move their Genesis business — to an exclusive facility or an adaptive exclusive with some shared service back at their Hyundai dealership. Or to resign the Genesis franchise if their market or their business plans really don't support expanding that. More and more retailers understand that engaging in the Keystone program and pursuing achievement of all the Keystone metrics is the path to maximizing their success as a Genesis retailer.
This year, you'll have the G70, G80, G90 sedans and the Electrified G80 when it arrives. Will Genesis have too many sedans?
The sedan business has been very, very successful for Genesis retailers. It makes up a solid third of our volume. What we find especially in the G80 and the G90 segments, where there are less entries, is that those two are achieving some remarkable segment shares. It's not uncommon if you look at a primary market area of a successful Genesis retailer to find that the G80 and the G90 have moved up to No. 2 in those segments.
Have you seen customer interest yet in the coming Genesis EVs?
In our digital retailing center, we have a waitlist developed for electric Genesis models, both the SUV and the sedan. What's happened with the EV segments is that it's no longer, "Oh, I want a green car." Customers want to have the user experience that is now available in the EVs, which in many cases is superior to the user experience that they have become accustomed to in their ICE vehicles. Genesis is a design brand and we anticipate continued innovation and leadership in our EV designs. And we think that with the launch of the GV60 we are going to stake our claim that Genesis is a leader in the premium EV SUV segment.
How have Genesis dealers adapted to tight inventories?
Like every brand, Genesis retailers updated their strategies in 2021, especially in the second half of the year when ground stock really became very, very tight. Much more accomplishment in digital retailing and pipeline sales. All of our production is offshore. We don't have any domestically produced models for Genesis, so the in-transit times for all of our models is much longer than any of the competitors that have a North American plant. So, we've really had to work closely with Genesis Motor America and we're still prioritizing better estimated time of arrival from our transportation company, so we can give the client a better idea of when a particular model they are interested in will be arriving. And then once that client purchases that pipeline unit, we need to be able to give accurate, reliable updates on the estimated time of arrival of that unit.
Do you think there are any lessons learned for inventory levels going forward?
A little scarcity is not a bad thing in our industry. And we hope that all the OEMs have kind of learned the lesson that overproduction and having inventory chasing customers is not as good as having a bunch of customers chasing inventory. We have very short memories in this industry, so I don't suspect we'll remember all of the positives of some of the scarcity that's been introduced into our industry.
How sustainable are current vehicle margin and profitability levels as inventory levels improve?
For a lot of dealers I talk to, and even for us, our Genesis business is our most profitable brand in terms of return on sales. It's very efficient. Part of that is because it's sharing space in the Hyundai facility. So, it doesn't yet have the full expense structure that it will have the day it moves into its exclusive facility.
Genesis profitability is at all-time record levels. Our return on sales for Genesis is probably where Porsche and Mercedes-Benz have aspired to over the years. The keyword is sustainability. We're working with Genesis leadership on the dealer profitability profile in exclusive facilities, particularly in fixed operations. Not only is the transition to EV rapid, but we don't have decades of internal combustion-engine sales that will leave us with a high quantity of ICE vehicles to service in our shops. We will not have the same profile on service and parts gross profit that Lexus, BMW, Mercedes and Audi have. So, we've addressed that with Genesis Motor America and we're looking for additional support for all the departments in a Genesis standalone facility as a result.
 
Last edited:
From a recent interview with the chairman of the Genesis National Dealer Advisory Council, who is also the owner of Genesis of Cherry Hill in Marlton, N.J:



It's no wonder the independent Hyundai dealerships are so adamant about not building standalone showrooms for Genesis when they can rake in profits that exceed Porsche with the current setup.
Ofcourse...selling higher profit vehicles when the Hyundai side of the business is basically covering all your overhead. That overhead also being much less than other luxury brand dealerships have in the first place

However...I am sure you have seen the posts online where people say they were turned off by what they dont consider to be a true luxury experience
So to appeal to the larger element of luxury buyers in the United States they are going to have to have free standing dealerships

Warren
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
it's not the building that will lose me.
It's not honoring (providing) the services you offer in your sales pitch.
the concierge service is one of the things that made us decide to go ahead and get the 80 over the other cars we were considering.
But dealers don't want to honor it????????
That will lose me quickly.
 
it's not the building that will lose me.
It's not honoring (providing) the services you offer in your sales pitch.
the concierge service is one of the things that made us decide to go ahead and get the 80 over the other cars we were considering.
But dealers don't want to honor it????????
That will lose me quickly.
If and when the brand gets enough traction to have a significant amount of free standing dealers, I am betting that will change
At that point they will have to focus on a luxury experience to be able to compete
Right now people are just dealing with a " Hyundai experience" for the most part

I am also going to bet if and when they have a significant amount of free standing dealers , that what I call the "cash grab" experience will start
What I mean by that is that a high over head, smaller volume dealership tends to nickel and dime you and offer a significant amount of high dollar ( low impact) services
In fact I would say the best service and luxury experience I have ever had was at a Mercedes dealer that I used to patronize in Dallas Texas
Impeccable service in an impeccable facility, but all of that was certainly not free or even discounted as evidenced by what they charged

Warren
 
From a recent interview with the chairman of the Genesis National Dealer Advisory Council, who is also the owner of Genesis of Cherry Hill in Marlton, N.J:



It's no wonder the independent Hyundai dealerships are so adamant about not building standalone showrooms for Genesis when they can rake in profits that exceed Porsche with the current setup.
I will also add that Genesis is probably also selling more models than Porsche due to the newer GV models which is just as nice or maybe even nicer than the Porche SUV models for a lower price. SUV models are a brands main profit producer. Combine that without the stand alone dealer cost means major profit gains for Hyundai/Genesis.
 
I will also add that Genesis is probably also selling more models than Porsche due to the newer GV models which is just as nice or maybe even nicer than the Porche SUV models for a lower price. SUV models are a brands main profit producer. Combine that without the stand alone dealer cost means major profit gains for Hyundai/Genesis.
Completely agree with your last sentence
They have the Hyundai sales and service covering most, if not all , of their overhead
When( and if) they have freestanding dealerships with all the typical luxury amenities and prime locations we shall see how that shakes out

Warren
 
I don't think it's a When (and if) at all. They either do it, or they will fail.
I will not buy another Genesis unless they turn it around and honor the service they suggest they have when you buy.
Who else will be "one and done" if things don't change?
 
I don't think it's a When (and if) at all. They either do it, or they will fail.
I will not buy another Genesis unless they turn it around and honor the service they suggest they have when you buy.
Who else will be "one and done" if things don't change?
I have said many times over the years that Americans want the luxury car " experience" and are willing to pay for it...that being said the Genesis brand will never sell in volume in the United States without luxury dealership in place
I cant imagine that we will see much growth in that regard in the next 3-5 years

In my home state of Texas, which is a HUGE luxury market for automobiles where Mercedes, BMW and Lexus have many many mega sized dealers all over the state
Genesis does not have one

The other part...that I find comical. My local Genesis/Hyundai dealer charges $35.00 an hour more for Genesis/Equus/Hyundai Genesis vehicle service now, about mirroring what the Lexus dealer charges per labor hour
While there is an attached Genesis showroom front and a showroom that holds 3 cars...the rest of the experience( service, waiting room etc) is all the same as Hyundai
Needless to say,its not up to the level of the local Lexus dealer total experience

Warren
 
I don't think it's a When (and if) at all. They either do it, or they will fail.
I will not buy another Genesis unless they turn it around and honor the service they suggest they have when you buy.
Who else will be "one and done" if things don't change?
Change what? My dealer always gave me the service suggested so no complaints. Concierge or loaner was always available.
______________________________

Help support this site so it can continue supporting you!
 
Change what? My dealer always gave me the service suggested so no complaints. Concierge or loaner was always available.
Change it to a consistent luxury car dealership experience across the brand to be the equivalent( at a minimum) of what is given and expected at other luxury vehicle brands

Sounds like you have been very lucky

Warren
 
For the last Q, Genesis sold almost as many vehicles as Porsche.

In Jan, Porsches were sold, on avg., $1,721 above MSRP.

Genesis was close behind at $1,603 over list.

Audi was at $1,325.

MB at $719.

Lexus at $235.

BMW at -$199 below list.

So, with minimal overhead, can see how Genesis dealerships, on avg., are more profitable right now than either Porsche or MB.
 
For the last Q, Genesis sold almost as many vehicles as Porsche.

In Jan, Porsches were sold, on avg., $1,721 above MSRP.

Genesis was close behind at $1,603 over list.

Audi was at $1,325.

MB at $719.

Lexus at $235.

BMW at -$199 below list.

So, with minimal overhead, can see how Genesis dealerships, on avg., are more profitable right now than either Porsche or MB.
Not enough information there to prove anything

How much average profit per unit and what is the average dealer overhead( per unit) for the brand location franchise?
And once again...with the Hyundai ( connected) business at the Genesis dealerships their overhead has got to be far far less

Would be helpful to show many cars sold and the average selling price as well....I bet they are wildly different in the list you provided

Warren
 
^ I'm sure the Chair of the Genesis Dealership Council has access to nos./data that we aren't privy to; nonetheless, as had stated, his claim seems to have merit.

While, including dealer margin, Porsche dealers net more, on avg., per vehicle, per publicly available data (sales volume, ATP above MSRP), the delta doesn't seem to be big enough where Genesis dealerships can't more than make up for the shortfall via considerably lower overhead - which you, yourself, have acknowledged a couple of times (you sure like to argue over nothing).

Now, of course, the equation would be different if there presently were a network of stand alone Genesis dealerships and all the costs that entails.

But as model lineup and sales continue to increase (GV60, Electrified GV70 and G80, new G90, etc.), Genesis should continue to be quite profitable for its franchisees even with the additional overhead.
 
^ I'm sure the Chair of the Genesis Dealership Council has access to nos./data that we aren't privy to; nonetheless, as had stated, his claim seems to have merit.

While, including dealer margin, Porsche dealers net more, on avg., per vehicle, per publicly available data (sales volume, ATP above MSRP), the delta doesn't seem to be big enough where Genesis dealerships can't more than make up for the shortfall via considerably lower overhead - which you, yourself, have acknowledged a couple of times (you sure like to argue over nothing).

Now, of course, the equation would be different if there presently were a network of stand alone Genesis dealerships and all the costs that entails.

But as model lineup and sales continue to increase (GV60, Electrified GV70 and G80, new G90, etc.), Genesis should continue to be quite profitable for its franchisees even with the additional overhead.
Not sure that it makes sense to compare Porsche...since a good percentage of their sales are for vehicles that are over $100K

You certainly like to pull out "factoids" that are missing important details

Then you use those " factoids" to speculate even further

Some of those brands you mentioned have models that sell, in volume, for twice as much in price( or more) as anything Genesis has

That makes it likely a completely different market and different buyer

But anyway...when( and if) Genesis gains a national free standing dealer network we shall see

Warren
 
^ I'm sure the Chair of the Genesis Dealership Council has access to nos./data that we aren't privy to; nonetheless, as had stated, his claim seems to have merit.

While, including dealer margin, Porsche dealers net more, on avg., per vehicle, per publicly available data (sales volume, ATP above MSRP), the delta doesn't seem to be big enough where Genesis dealerships can't more than make up for the shortfall via considerably lower overhead - which you, yourself, have acknowledged a couple of times (you sure like to argue over nothing).

Now, of course, the equation would be different if there presently were a network of stand alone Genesis dealerships and all the costs that entails.

But as model lineup and sales continue to increase (GV60, Electrified GV70 and G80, new G90, etc.), Genesis should continue to be quite profitable for its franchisees even with the additional overhead.
I found this " presentation" about Auto company profitability overall and profit per unit
if this information is accurate..hats off to Toyota for its profits and hats off the Mercedes for profitability per automobile sold
I find these numbers amazing..if they are accurate


Warren
 
I found this " presentation" about Auto company profitability overall and profit per unit
if this information is accurate..hats off to Toyota for its profits and hats off the Mercedes for profitability per automobile sold
I find these numbers amazing..if they are accurate


Warren
Some of the numbers are not what I'd have guessed. Though I would expect an S class to be more profitable than an Accent.
 
Some of the numbers are not what I'd have guessed. Though I would expect an S class to be more profitable than an Accent.
And I am betting an S class costs far more to engineer and build than an Accent
Can you imagine the development costs on a Mercedes S class?
As I have said many times when people pull out luxury brands on here and try to compare them...its apples and oranges many times

That being said ..Toyota is a very comparable( apples to apples) company and they seem to be " killing it"

Warren
 
I found this " presentation" about Auto company profitability overall and profit per unit
if this information is accurate..hats off to Toyota for its profits and hats off the Mercedes for profitability per automobile sold
I find these numbers amazing..if they are accurate


Warren
What a crappy video. They used Hyundai Motor Group's global sales numbers, which include Hyundai/Kia/Genesis- but then used only Hyundai Motor Co's profits, which include only Hyundai and Genesis vehicles. Thus all their calculations were all wrong because they forgot to include Kia's profits.

Funny enough, Motor1 did their own 2021 profit analysis yesterday and turned out a much more accurate result.

motor1-numbers-2021-profits.jpg


 
it's not the building that will lose me.
It's not honoring (providing) the services you offer in your sales pitch.
the concierge service is one of the things that made us decide to go ahead and get the 80 over the other cars we were considering.
But dealers don't want to honor it????????
That will lose me quickly.

For me, it is for sure the experience that turned me from the Genesis brand. I love my G80, but the dealer and Genesis customer service was really awful. My wife recently got a new SUV and she loved everything about the GV80 but after my experience with the Genesis dealer and Genesis support she would not buy from them. She wound up purchasing an Acura which was a great sales experience.
Such a shame with Genesis when they have such a great product but bad support.
 
Back
Top