• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Help Me Pick A CPO Genny for Mom

CPOGuy

Hasn't posted much yet...
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Hello Everyone. I come here today hopeful to get my Mom in the Genny club.

What I am trying to do right now is nail down the best choice of Genesis for my mother, based on her driving habits... finances... etc. I'm hoping you Genny experts can steer me in the right direction on which year/model/package will fit her best. So here goes...

Basically, my mother has been buying brand new Fords, Buicks, and so forth the past few car cycles of her life. To me, these cars and their 3/36,000: 5/60,000 Warranty have been terrible choices for her, because she does not drive that much (perhaps 8,000 miles per year). Thus, the warranties expire before she has really racked up miles and she ends up paying out of pocket for all the repairs that don't occur until after 50 or 60,000 miles.

She doesn't know better so she was ready to do this all over again with a new Nissan or one of the others.... but I've stopped her and tried to make her understand why this is bad for her... and how CPO programs work... and how a 5/60k Basic: 10/100k Power Train Genesis (from in service date) is a better car with a far better warranty for her and her low mile driving habits.

I seem to have convinced her (pre-test drive and all that) that this is best for her, so now the pressure is on for me to find the right year/model/options that fit her best.

Here is what I can tell you about her, and hopefully some of you can help steer me to the right car or two to pick from...

----------------------

1. She is not tech savvy at all. Never touched a Nav screen in her life. She only makes 1 or 2 drives a year that requires directions. I usually print them out for her and that works fine enough.

2. She's not going to know any difference between a Lexicon 14 speaker and 17 speaker system. I understand 14 Lexicon is standard with every year of the Genesis. Correct me if I'm wrong.

3. A sunroof would be nice. Not essential, but I think she's like it even though she claims she doesn't care about that.

4. The rear window shade would be really nice, but not essential.

5. A V6 is fine for her, but if a V8 is simply a better car, great.

6. Heated Seats appear to be standard, but cooled seats would be a great bonus... for her as a driver and her passengers. I'm having a hard time understanding what year/models have cooled seats (driver only? passenger? back seats?).

7. The backup camera sounds nice, but I don't think she's gonna care about looking behind her for 8 more years or so.

8. This is very important... she will KILL ME if she gets a car with electronic goodies she doesn't care about that end up costing her big $$$ to repair. I also don't think she'd be very happy about spending big $$$ to upgrade a Nav unit every couple years (although, I don't know why anyone would want to upgrade all that often, unless there are new roads being built around you often, or you travel alot).

9. She's getting a CPO, because a brand new Genny is above her budget, so 2009-2011's are the choices... although I'd like to go with a 2010 or 11 if possible for warranty purposes. If I'm advised to go very basic with the car, then 2009 is a possibility if you think the most basic model would avoid all the famous "electronic problems".


-------------------------------------

So basically, I'm trying to get her the nicest car possible while minimizing her risk to future electrical problems/technology costs (and on a CPO, they have a very short warranty left in terms of certain electronics).

My initial thoughts are that any Tech Package car is a no go, and the most Basic Premium Package is the best bet for her. I'm not sure where the "in-between" Premium Nav (non Tech Package) models fit into this. I seem to read that the touch-screen Nav is less costly to deal with if there are problems/updates, but perhaps I should avoid any Navigation units at all? I'm not really sure what else I'm losing when I take away all Navigation models.


So that is the basic criteria for how I'm trying to select a year/model. If any additional information is needed, please ask.


--------------------------


I do have a few reservations about the Genesis that makes me question whether this is even the right car for her. I'll list those in case anyone wants to address them.

1. She live in Connecticut. It snows in Connecticut. Wet leaves in Connecticut. Black Ice in Connecticut. I have told her its R-Wheel Drive and that it might be best she drive a "snow car" 2-3 months of the year. She seems ok with the idea if needed. I know some suggest just switch tires every November and March, but this is a 60 year old lady. She's not going to be changing 4 tires twice every year and rolling them into her garage for storage.

I'm also concerned with people talking about this car having problems in the rain/standing water. It's one thing to hear these things and buy a car for yourself, and another thing to hear these things and suggest someone else buy this car.

2. Maintenance Costs. I'm wondering if perhaps I am fooling myself a bit with the Maintenance Costs of this car (things that wear out, not under warranty, oil changes, etc.). I want to believe she'd be getting a Luxury Car with "typical" Hyundai Maintenance Costs. How good or bad is it to replace things that wear out?

Oil changes sound fine, but Brake Pads, Filters, etc.? I've also heard complaints about the back tires wearing out fast on this car.



That's about all I can think of off the top of my head right now. Hopefully a few people can chime in and put me in the right direction. Thanks to anyone who offers their opinion!
 
Seems to me a Genesis is way more car than she needs. Even the basest of base models will have a lot of features she won't want or care about, and cars with few option packages won't be easy to find. How about a FWD Sonata? They are very nice cars and maybe a better fit for your mom.
 
After reading this is sounds like your mother would appreciate a new Elantra or a base model Sonata or Optima etc. Save money, get brand new, and doesn't overwhelm her. It doens't sound like the Genesis is a car for your mother at all.
 
1. The Base Model Genesis does not have Nav, but probably hard to find a used one (not that many new ones were made).

2. Base Model has 7 speaker system that sounds fairly good but does not have surround sound (rear speaker delay like home theater system). Should be more than good enough for mom.

3. The Premium and Tech packages have sunroof. Base Model does not.

4. Only on Tech Package.

5. V6 is fine unless your mom is street racer.

6. Tech Package has cooled seats for driver. Not sure when it was added to front passenger. I don't thnk it is available for rear, but you can check Genesis website for 2012 specs.

7. Only Tech Package has rear camera.

8. Depending on the model year (since you are looking at used) the Premium package may or may not have Nav. All Tech Packages have nav. It will cost a fortune to repair (warranty is only 36K miles / 36-months even for original owner) like the other electronic systems. Therefore, in order to keep from getting killed, she will need to buy a Platinum extended warranty to cover these items for 10 years, or get the Base Model and buy a Garmin with free life-time map updates for $120.

9. The Base model will avoid most (if not all) of the electronic problems, but 2009 model has too stiff of a supension for your mom. It was upgraded in 2010 and again in 2012, to make it more comfortable.

1a. Probably should not even consider a RWD in that kind of weather unless she has another car to drive in bad weather. There are lots of nice FWD cars on the market, including the new Sonata or Azera.

2a. Maintenance costs are pretty reasonable on Genesis, since plugs and transmission fluid don't get changed until 100K miles.

Overall, I think you would be crazy to recommend a used Genesis for your mom. A brand new loaded Sonata or other car would be better in her situation IMO.

Also, I am somewhat ignorant about the CPO warranty. Normally, the 100K miles / 10-year drivetrain warranty on Hyundai's is only for orginal owner. Is there an exception for CPO cars?
 
Also, I am somewhat ignorant about the CPO warranty. Normally, the 100K miles / 10-year drivetrain warranty on Hyundai's is only for orginal owner. Is there an exception for CPO cars?

A CPO warranty will restore to original full factory coverage 10/100 (remaining) for second owner... if the CPO used car was purchased off Hyundai dealership.

Agree with the other posts... a CPO Genesis is not recommended due to your requirements and her needs.
Have you looked at a CPO Azera (FWD) with a V6 3.8 (between a Sonata and Genesis)?

[What you are describing is a Toyota Avalon - one was passed down to me 2 years ago thru a will (1998 - 50,000 miles). Did the whole maintenance job (plugs, wires, water pump. belt, complete all fluid change, brakes) and gave to Mother In Law for a reliability factor.]
 
What you are describing is a Toyota Avalon - one was passed down to me 2 years ago thru a will (1998 - 50,000 miles). Did the whole maintenance job (plugs, wires, water pump. belt, complete all fluid change, brakes) and gave to Mother In Law for a reliability factor.]/QUOTE]

Gotta agree with the Avalon idea. My Mom drives one and it is perfect match for her as far as having the technology she needs such as ABS, Trac Control, etc. and the comfort items she wants. Both front seats cooled and heated..(Hello Hyundai, anyone home?).

Her's is the limited without the tech package, so no Nav, No Satellite radio, No laser cruise control, etc...

The Hyundai Bumper-Bumper warranty is a bit toothless anyway (excludes electronics??). For the powertrain and everything else, you can get a very comprehensive aftermarket warranty even on a well used car...

Richard
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
A new 2012 top line Elantra seems like the car for your mom. Elantra is the north american car of the year for 2012. Or maybe the new 2013 Azera.
 
For reference...


CPO Warranties:

Power Train:
Hyundai: 10/100,000 from in service date
Mitsubishi: 10/100,000 from in service date
Acura: 7/100,000 from in service date
Infinity: 6/100,000 from in service date (Comprehensive the same)
Lincoln: 6/100,000 from in service date
Lexus: 3/36,000 from when you buy the cpo (Comprehensive the same)


Comprehensive:
Infinity: 6/100,000 from in service date
Acura: 5/62,000 from in service date
Hyundai: 5/60,000 from in service date
Mitsubishi: 5/60,000 from in service date
Suzuki: 4/48,000 from in service date
Lexus: 3/36,000 from when you buy the cpo
Lincoln: 3 month/3,000 from when you buy the cpo

Volvo: 6/100,000 from in service date
Cadillac: 6/100,000 from in service date
Volkswagon: 5/60,000 from in sevice date
 
Last edited:
What you are describing is a Toyota Avalon - one was passed down to me 2 years ago thru a will (1998 - 50,000 miles). Did the whole maintenance job (plugs, wires, water pump. belt, complete all fluid change, brakes) and gave to Mother In Law for a reliability factor.

I've looked at the Avalon. Looks like a great car. Here is the thing though when you start stacking side by side...

A new Avalon is going to run well into the $30's.

A CPO Avalon will be less (mid to upper $20's say). Let's say you got a 2010 CPO Avalon. You'd get a 1 year Comprehensive Warranty and about 5 years/100k left on the Power Train Warranty.

If you got a 2010 Genesis in the upper $20's, you're getting about 3 years/60k left on the Comprehensive Warranty and 8 years/100k left on the Power Train.

In other words, you are arguably driving a finer automobile and getting a better warranty for a similar price.


Buying a "brand new" car is like a fork in my eye because I absolutely hate that depreciation hit. I'd rather let some other guy buy a new $40k car and pick it up for $28k a year or so later than buy my own brand new car for $30k and have it be worth $24k once I drive off the lot.
 
Last edited:
How long is a "car cycle" for her? If it is likely to be 3 years and out in either car, then the warranty is out of the picture as a deciding factor.

IMO...Genny is not arguably better or worse than the Toyota....My Mom's 2007 Avalon interior is holding up much better than I expect my Genesis to do. Mainly the seat leather in the Genesis is too soft and already shows wear in certain areas at less than 30K miles. Mechanically, the Toyota has never missed a beat. The Toyota Keyless entry/start is much more thoughtful than the Genesis. It opens without a button and turns on the interior lights when you approach it with the Fob. She has no squeaks/rattles or other annoyances...
______________________________

Help support this site so it can continue supporting you!
 
How long is a "car cycle" for her? If it is likely to be 3 years and out in either car, then the warranty is out of the picture as a deciding factor.

7 years... 8 years? She's had her current car nearly 10 years. She doesn't drive that many miles per year, so its kind of silly for her to be swapping cars every 3 or 4 years. She's just going to lose out faster on depreciation and such.

That is why the years of these warranties are so important. The miles are largely irrelevant as they years are likely to expire first for her.

Based on analyzing all the new car and CPO warranties out there, the cars that make the most sense are...

-------------

Hyundai Genesis CPO (remainder of 5 year b2b warranty and 10 year power train warranty)

Hyundai Azera (probably new if the 2012 is that much better)

(I don't think the Sonata or lower models will be what she wants to drive the next decade. She's earned the right to drive the nicest car she's ever had now)

Kia Cadenza (have to see the price when it comes out)

Kia Optima SX (probably new, because CPO Kia's don't have any Comprehensive b-2-b Warranty coverage. Only power train.)

Infiniti CPO (would have to be a 2011 or newer to get most of remaining 6 year b-2-b warranty.)

Acura CPO (would have to be a 2011 or newer to get most of remaining 5 year b-2-b and 7 year power train warranty)

Volvo CPO (would have to be a 2011 or newer to get most of remaining 6 year b-2-b warranty)

Lexus CPO (the play here is to get one of the oldest Lexus CPO's you can for $17k or so, then drive it 3 years it is covered with b-2-b warranty, then sell it and move on to the next car, unless you really fall in love with it)


There really aren't any other cars + warranty combinations that make sense to me.



High $20k's would be about what her budget will be. Perhaps willing to go a little higher for the Hyundai's and Kia because of their warranty.
 
Last edited:
7 years... 8 years? She's had her current car nearly 10 years. She doesn't drive that many miles per year, so its kind of silly for her to be swapping cars every 3 or 4 years. She's just going to lose out faster on depreciation and such.

That is why the years of these warranties are so important. The miles are largely irrelevant as they years are likely to expire first for her.
Based on my experience, getting a reliable car and maintaining it well is more important than the warranty. Anyone can offer a warranty, and who wants to spend the time trying to get it fixed?

As far as deserving to drive a nice car, maybe she deserves to have a brand new car also. I think you should let her do some test drives and let her decide if she wants a new brand new loaded Sonata/Accord/Camry (or other car) or a used Genesis. Not to mention that it sounds like she would be better off with a FWD car.
 
Based on my experience, getting a reliable car and maintaining it well is more important than the warranty. Anyone can offer a warranty, and who wants to spend the time trying to get it fixed?

As far as deserving to drive a nice car, maybe she deserves to have a brand new car also. I think you should let her do some test drives and let her decide if she wants a new brand new loaded Sonata/Accord/Camry (or other car) or a used Genesis. Not to mention that it sounds like she would be better off with a FWD car.

Fair points, and of course the decision is hers.

The warranty does matter because you can get a car with a reliable REPUTATION, but that does not mean you are getting a reliable car. Its luck of the draw.
 
Fair points, and of course the decision is hers.

The warranty does matter because you can get a car with a reliable REPUTATION, but that does not mean you are getting a reliable car. Its luck of the draw.

Agreed with the warranty completely. You can take perfect care of your 'highly reliable' car, but when something goes that doesn't pay for it, but a warranty does. Buying a warranty you're hedging your risk. Over the very very long haul you'll lose. But, for instance, I budget my monthly expenses and am aggressive with saving in tax sheltered accounts and even my non-tax sheltered accounts would be vulnerable to cap-gains if you sell unexpectedly. For this reason I have decided I have a low tolerance for unexpected costs in my monthly budget and therefore a warranty is important. If someone decides that, it very well may be the best decision for them.
 
As a fellow Nutmegger, and from experience, forget RWD, especially if Mom will be driving in the hilly parts of the state. There are just too many suitable alternatives available.
 
Just saw some video of the Kia Cadenza.

When the hell is that baby coming out and how much is the MSRP? I can't find a rumored price anywhere.
 
As a fellow Nutmegger, and from experience, forget RWD, especially if Mom will be driving in the hilly parts of the state. There are just too many suitable alternatives available.

Disappointing to hear. She has no problem using a winter vehicle (she wants to have a spare car anyways), but perhaps it's not worth it.

I'm watching video of the Azera, and it is nice... but it's still not as beautiful as the Genesis.
 
No need to be dissapointed, If Mom's ok with a second winter car, and you have your heart set on a Genesis, she'll be fine with the V6 with premium pkg; plenty of creature comforts she'll appreciate and none of the tech stuff she'll find of little use.
 
The warranty does matter because you can get a car with a reliable REPUTATION, but that does not mean you are getting a reliable car. Its luck of the draw.
I didn't say the warranty doesn't matter. It is a factor. But I personally think that getting a car known to be reliable is more important.
 
Back
Top