• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Hyundai's luxury Genesis isn't super

ultra63

Been here awhile...
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
297
Reaction score
105
Points
43
Location
FL
Genesis Model Year
2022
Genesis Model Type
Genesis GV70
Certainly a lukewarm review of the Gen fron Detroit.

December 18, 2008


Hyundai's luxury Genesis isn't super, but it is loaded

BY MARK PHELAN
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST

If you can't build a great car, build a car with a lot of great stuff in it.

That strategy has served Hyundai well. The South Korean automaker has grown from a bargain-basement brand into a global player by packing its vehicles with more features and selling them at a lower price than the competition.

That "if not better, more" philosophy is on display in the 2009 Genesis, the biggest, most powerful and best-equipped car the automaker has ever offered in the United States.

The rear-wheel drive Genesis raises Hyundai's game with a long list of features and a beautifully designed and carefully trimmed interior. Luxury brands like BMW, Cadillac, Infiniti, Lexus, Lincoln and Mercedes-Benz would be proud to offer the Genesis's lovely and spacious passenger compartment.

On all those fronts, the Genesis constitutes a major leap for Hyundai, but the big car still lands in the middle of the pack of large sedans priced from the upper $20s to low $40s.

The look and feel of the interior is the Genesis's only clear win as it competes with models ranging from the sporty Chrysler 300C and Pontiac G8 to the practical Ford Taurus and Toyota Avalon.

The Genesis is Hyundai's first heavyweight contender, but it fails to throw a knockout punch because of unexceptional fuel economy, derivative styling and cumbersome controls for its optional navigation and audio systems.

Genesis prices, like its upscale interior and rear-drive layout, set a new standard for Hyundai. A base 2009 Genesis 3.8 powered by a 290-horsepower 3.8-liter V6 costs $32,250. The top-of-the-line $37,250 Genesis 4.6 offers the first V8 Hyundai has sold in the United States, a powerful 4.6-liter 368-horsepower engine. Both models come with standard six-speed automatic transmissions. The V6 gets an Aisin gearbox, while the V8 comes with a ZF transmission.

I tested nicely equipped versions of both cars: a $35,250 3.8 and $41,250 4.6. I had more time to drive the 4.6, so this review focuses on that model. All prices exclude destination charges.

While most automakers have turned to rear-wheel drive platforms to produce sporty performance sedans with precise handling, Hyundai harked back to the soft-riding days of Buick and Lexus for the Genesis' handling. The suspension cushions bumps as the Genesis floats down the road in old-style comfort other brands have abandoned as they chase BMW-style performance chic. The downside is a tendency to body roll that discourages enthusiastic driving.

The interior is remarkably quiet, free of vibration, wind and road noise. The Genesis' cab offers a level of isolation that matches the silence of a Lexus LS.

The powertrains are tuned for confident passing and highway cruising. Acceleration is less invigorating than the horsepower figures might lead you to expect, because the engines produce less torque or peak at higher r.p.m. than the Chrysler 300 or Pontiac G8.

Hyundai's V6 and V8 engines both run on regular fuel, but the company recommends premium for maximum power from the V8. The increased output of eight horsepower -- to 375 -- and 9 pound-feet of torque -- to 333 -- probably won't strike most drivers as worth the additional cost.

A likely fuel economy penalty for running regular in the V8 may be more noticeable.

The EPA rated the Genesis' fuel economy ratings at 18 m.p.g. city/27 m.p.g. highway for the V6 and 17 m.p.g. city/25 m.p.g. highway for the V8. The EPA used premium fuel when it tested the V8. Drivers who choose to run regular can probably expect some deterioration in fuel economy. That usually happens in engines that are tuned for maximum performance with premium gasoline.

For comparison, the 300, G8, Taurus and Avalon all passed EPA muster with regular gas. The front-drive Taurus and Avalon V6 models got EPA ratings of 18 m.p.g. city/28 highway and 19 city/28 highway, respectively.

V8 models of the 300 and G8 achieved EPA ratings of 16 city/25 highway and 15 city/24 highway, respectively.

The net effect is that running premium fuel in a V8 Genesis will add $131 to $213 to your annual fuel bill compared with driving a 300C or G8 GT, according to the EPA's calculations.

The look and feel of the big Hyundai's interior is first-class all the way.

Every surface is either padded soft-touch trim or tastefully applied wood or brightwork. A strip of warm chocolate brown leather across the center of the instrument panel -- where most automakers would place a strip of wood -- in the V8 I tested was especially appealing.

The gauges are clear and easy to read, and the climate controls are simple. A round control knob for navigation and audio systems in the V8 I tested required too many steps to perform some basic tasks, however. The navigation system had a big, clear display, but was poorly integrated with the audio system, refusing to show what disc, song or iPod track was playing when the map was displayed.

The optional audio system is excellent. Hyundai says the Genesis is the only car other than Rolls-Royce with an audio system by Lexicon. Sound clarity was exemplary, and the 528 available watts are more than sufficient.

Passenger room is a generous 109.4 cubic feet. The trunk checks in at 15.9 cubic feet. The passenger compartment tops the 300, Avalon, G8 and Taurus. The Genesis' trunk size trails the G8 and Taurus, but is larger than the 300 and Avalon.


http://www.freep.com/article/20081218/COL14/812180479/1081
 
Seems to me that he missed a few points - Like a chey Cavalier gets better gas milage, an' a VW does too, an' a Prius! I mean, if yoiu're going to do an apples to oranges comparison . . .

And then there is the fact that the Genesis is DUAL Certified to run on BOTH regular and premium . . . and I guess "Best in Class" mileage doesn't count either.
Body lean? Did he even DRIVE an Avalon?

Well, at least he got the interior right . . . 'cept maybe he didn't even TRY a thumb drive - mine shows everything!

Yeah, you nailed it - NO bailout for him!!!
 
Wow...obviously he didnt spend too much time in the V8.

I am more than willing to shell out "$131-$213" more a YEAR for my V8.
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
What do you expect from a journalist based in Detroit. Hyundai is one of the car makers that is killing the Big 3 (soon, Bye bye 3?). The controller is simple to use. Obviously, he had never touched the i-Drive in a bimmer. Cornering is flat, minimal body roll. I bet this guy got paid by the Detroit chamber of commerce to write this review.
 
That was pretty much my thoughts too. Notice he's a free-press writer - which means he does not work for any particular company, just submits articles. He may have been contracted to do this article. My opinion, anyway.

If he can't use the AV controller then he probably can't use a computer. If you can use windows or a Mac then you can use the controller...it's one of the most intuitive I've seen. BMW is a nightmare compared to the Genesis controller. I guess anything harder than pushing a button labeled "on/off" is tricky for this guy. Whatever.
 
Certainly a lukewarm review of the Gen fron Detroit.

December 18, 2008


Hyundai's luxury Genesis isn't super, but it is loaded

BY MARK PHELAN
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST

If you can't build a great car, build a car with a lot of great stuff in it.

Seems a little biased right off the top...or is that 'jealousy'??
 
"The look and feel of the interior is the Genesis's only clear win as it competes with models ranging from the sporty Chrysler 300C and Pontiac G8 to the practical Ford Taurus and Toyota Avalon."

Obviously he has never been in a Mercedes, Infinity, Jaguar, BMW, Acura, etc! If he was he would realize that the Genesis is on par with all of them! But then Gettelfinger is probably makeing his house payments.
 
DAMN! I could of had a taurus!

nuff said.....
 
A definitely biased review and totally inaccurate. Anyone thinking about purchasing a Genesis that reads this should go drive one. I am sure your review would not mirror this one! When is the last time the big 3 made a vehicle with all of these bells and wistles for under 40K?


I'm waiting!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I am not anti big 3 but the lesson to be learned has been out there for decades but not at $80 per hour and no show pay at 95%, etc., etc.. Thank the AWU.
 
I stopped reading when he started comparing the Genesis to a Ford Taurus. Quack.

Remember now, that's a "practical" Taurus....which was dropped by Ford (due to sales, I suppose). Then they re-named the lovely "500" a Taurus, because that wasn't selling either...

Quack!

Dan
 
I generally find Detroit Free Press reviews to be pretty even-handed, but I haven't read that many before this.

His comparison to the fuel economy of the Taurus and Avalon is absurd. They're both significantly slower!

And he criticizes the V8 fuel economy and performance, but keeps the references to the (slightly) faster 300C and (noticeably) faster G8 a paragraph or two away from a reference to their fuel economy. They both do noticeably worse than the Genesis V8 on fuel.

Disappointing article.
 
There are so many things this guy gets wrong that I don't know where to begin. First...

The Genesis is Hyundai's first heavyweight contender, but it fails to throw a knockout punch because of unexceptional fuel economy, derivative styling and cumbersome controls for its optional navigation and audio systems.

So the Genesis IS a heavyweight contender! Great! Does it really have unexceptional fuel economy? Didn't Lexus become a successful "top tier" luxury sedan competitor with the derivatively styled LS? Are the optional navigation and audio system controls REALLY cumbersome? All wrong, wrong, wrong - which leaves the only true piece of information that being how the Genesis IS a heavyweight contender.

I used Edmunds.com to price a Chrysler 300C equipped similarly to the Genesis V8 I tested. The 300C totaled $42,315 -- or $1,065 more than the Hyundai. The Genesis had some features you can't get on the 300, like a rear camera for parking.

Is this guy serious?! Does build quality amount to nothing? This is a luxury car we're talking about here - does the silent interior and lack of wind noise amount to nothing? The technologies in the Genesis far exceed those found in the 300C... The 300C is LOUD (I own a 2007) with LOTS of road noise and LOTS of wind noise. The build quality is "okay" and there's nothing special about the navigation system. In fact, it was so bad - I didn't get it in my vehicle...

Bad, bad, bad, bad, bad review......
 
I stopped reading after a couple of sentences... though I should've known better... Reading someone from Detroit review an import
blowingup.gif
 
Back
Top