• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Edmunds: Genesis 4.6 vs GS350

jwaters943

Been here awhile...
Joined
Jun 28, 2008
Messages
1,318
Reaction score
7
Points
0
Location
Reno, NV
http://www.edmunds.com/insideline/d...Id=130686?tid=edmunds.il.home.photopanel..1.*

08.comparo.gs350.genesis.group.3.500.jpg


1st Place: Hyundai Genesis 4.6
Hyundai's biggest and best car runs with Lexus for a lot less money.

2nd Place: Lexus GS350
The midsize v6 Lexus is sweet-natured, beautiful and comfortable. But is the Lexus name worth more than $7k?

FWIW, they got to 60mph in 5.9 seconds w/ the Genesis and only 5.7 for the GS350. I wonder why their V8 test model was so slow. That's noticeably off from Motor Trend's time of 5.5 seconds.
 
Great article and a nice read. Thanks for posting this article.
 
I wonder why they didn't compare it to the LS460? I would think that would be more of a direct comparison. The price disparity would be greater, so I suppose that is the only reason. The car is sized more like the LS.

I have a LS460 SWB, and am looking forward to driving the Genesis and making my own comparison. ;) I think that the LS has the Genesis beat on features and prestige, but sometimes it's nice to be the new kid in town. :D

After reading about some of the problems that y'all are experiencing, I may wait to seriously consider the Genesis. I also like the Jaguar XF.....There are too many nice cars!
 
Thank you for posting up this review! It's okay to paste some of the article, ya know! :) In any event:

Edmunds said:
The driving experience is so like that of a Lexus LS 460, you couldn't tell the difference if your eyes were closed.

That is VERY impressive!!

Here's a little bit of the article:

Executive Editor Michael Jordan says:
It's tempting to dismiss the 2009 Hyundai Genesis without a thought. There's the familiar formal Hyundai grille leading a blend of sheet metal style and proportions from BMW and Lexus. There's the Lexus-style interior trimmed with Infiniti materials, an Infiniti-style dashboard information interface and an Audi-style console-mounted controller. And the driving experience is so like that of a Lexus LS 460, you couldn't tell the difference if your eyes were closed.

It's another step along the road to maturity by Hyundai, but it's easy to see a lack of confidence in these derivative choices by the Korean carmaker, a kind of corporate embarrassment that it can still recall those days of the 1960s when its factories were built with floors of hard-packed dirt.

And yet you see nothing of this crisis of confidence when you fly into Seoul, as the landscape is marked by buildings of incredible architectural boldness, a unique blend of Asian and Western style. Seoul is a city of substance and fierce pride, and it makes you wonder why Korean cars aren't the same.

It makes me think that Hyundai isn't showing us a copy of something but instead a pragmatic assembled example of what it has found to be the best automotive stuff on the planet. It's a kind of Toyota-goes-to-Nebraska approach to car-building, as if Hyundai asked the people what they want and then made sure to give it to them at a Wal-Mart price. You wait for the best technology to become affordable, then you give it a faintly fashionable appearance that people seem to like. It's a good idea.

The Hyundai Genesis V8 illustrates just how good an idea it is, because it drives just like a Lexus (a Lexus LS 460 that is; if you want a Lexus GS 350-style car, then the Genesis V6 is what you want). And yet the unknown quantity with this car is still the same as that of the first Mitsubishi-derived Hyundai Excel in 1986 — quality. We know this car has a great warranty, but will we still believe a year from now that it's a Lexus at half the price? I hope so, because no one wants to drive a Wal-Mart car, not even in Nebraska.

Read more (same article as link in original post)
 
FWIW, they got to 60mph in 5.9 seconds w/ the Genesis and only 5.7 for the GS350. I wonder why their V8 test model was so slow. That's noticeably off from Motor Trend's time of 5.5 seconds.

Edmunds almost always gets slower times than the other mainstream magazines.
 
Executive Editor Michael Jordan says:

And yet the unknown quantity with this car is still the same as that of the first Mitsubishi-derived Hyundai Excel in 1986 — quality. We know this car has a great warranty, but will we still believe a year from now that it's a Lexus at half the price? I hope so, because no one wants to drive a Wal-Mart car, not even in Nebraska.

Read more (same article as link in original post)


I expect more from the Executive Editor. He does realize this is 2008 and Hyundai is now rated above average for reliability, right?
 
You can compare all kinds of auto brands both foreign and domestic from 1986, and most were embarrassing by today's standards. I agree that was a cheap shot... it seems to be the only criticism reviews seem to fall back on.
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
Back
Top