Regarding the driver's skill argument, please let me know honestly...if the G70 manual RWD was available with 3.3 engine, would you still get the 2.0?
I absolutely would. We bought ours specifically because my son wanted to learn to drive manual and I wanted to introduce him to performance driving.
First, there is the obvious insurance premium advantage of the lesser HP car. This is especially true when we have a young male adult on the policy. And soon to be two of them!
Second, and more importantly... while more HP/TQ certainly can be more fun, there
is such a thing as too much of it when used as a learning tool. When you first get into performance driving, the goal is
not simply
to clock the fastest lap time. Rather. it is to learn the fundamentals:
1. Following the racing line.
2. Judging corner entry speed.
3 Managing weight transfer, both dive/squat and laterally.
4. Modulating throttle/brake control for optimum use of available tire traction.
None of these fundamentals requires big HP/TQ. In fact, having excessive amount can actually distract from the lessons at hand. Too much HP/TQ makes the throttle control more difficult and exaggerates the consequences of incorrect power application. Besides, it can teach bad habits by de-emphasizing momentum preservation. All that HP/TQ lets the driver get sloppy going into and through the corner and compensate by simply muscling out of it with raw power.
It is exactly the same - if not even more pronounced - when it comes to motorcycling. This is why most seasoned riders would recommend against bringing a liter-class sportbike to your first track day. A lighter and smaller cc bike is far easier to learn on, more fun,
and safer to boot. My track bunny is an old '05 Gixxer 600, even though I ride far larger and more powerful road bikes. If you talk to dirtbike riders, they'll tell you exactly the same thing.
I'm glad Genesis paired the 6MT with the 2.0T. It sets the tone of it as a momentum car, no different than that of the Miata or BRZ/GR86, or S2000, or any number of moderate HP pure
driver's cars. It teaches discipline that will, in time, make one a
fast driver. That, to me, is far more valuable
and desirable than simple a
fast car.