Well, we really don't know that yet, definitively. Certainly not in the US. The cars aren't here yet. I haven't seen a US-spec road test, let alone the assessments of real drivers. Nor do we have any data on reliability at this point. The dealer network is largely a work in progress. We don't even know all of the car specs, and Kia chopped a lot out of the
Stinger when it released in the US. Prices are yet to be announced and we have far less experience with the Genesis brand than we do with BMW. I'm hoping that it turns out to be true that the car will be a great bargain. But it inherently involves a bunch of unknowns and the associated risks. Incurring such risks needs to be offset by aggressive pricing.
I've owned a couple of BMWs. And I'm not rushing out to buy another at the price point they are selling for in comparison to what they have to offer. So, for me, a comparison to a BMW isn't a relative price anchor. More appropriate may be something like an
Infiniti Q50 RS400, and they're selling and leasing an extremely competitive prices these days, discounting aggressively. They offer an outstanding dealer experience, and the two I've owned have been great cars. I hope and think the G70 will be even better. But given the unkonwns, I'm not willing to pay a premium to make that bet. Sure, the Q50 RS400 has some limitations. But I know what they are up front and can do a more comprehensive analysis of the trade-offs. Can't yet say the same for the G70. At a great price point I'd run the risk. At something closer to established brands, not so much.