• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

what is the best tire to replace the rear passenger tire - tire has screw in the wall

sims11

Hasn't posted much yet...
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
Points
6
2011 4.6 Genesis. Done about 13K miles. Tires are all in good shape.

My choices are:
1. get a stock factory tire (Dunlop) - comes with standard Dunlop warranty
2. get a tire from Costco (Michelin) - comes with Costco's road hazard warranty

Considering that I am losing the tire due to a road hazard (a screw!!), I am inclined to go with option 2 above. Downside is that I will one odd tire.

Any thoughts?
 
Re: what is the best tire to replace the rear passenger tire - tire has screw in the

Never miss-match tires. An odd tire will cause handling problems due to difference in tread grip. Also different brand tires in the same size will have a different diameters.
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
Generally not considered a good idea to have different tires, especially on the same axle. I suspect that some tire installers might not even do it due to liability issues. You can call Costco and find out.
 
Never miss-match tires. An odd tire will cause handling problems due to difference in tread grip. Also different brand tires in the same size will have a different diameters.

Thanks for the advice. That is a big vote for the Dunlop - without any warranty... I reckon you know cars - looking at your signature.
 
Generally not considered a good idea to have different tires, especially on the same axle. I suspect that some tire installers might not even do it due to liability issues. You can call Costco and find out.

The Costco people were willing to order a Michelin tire. He said if it is not a all wheel drive then one different tire is ok. I did not decide on the spot.

Thanks for sharing!
 
Go to Discount Tire. Ask them how much they will give you for your "good tire" on trade in, and then get 2 tires from them. They are more inclined to give you more for your trade in if you buy the "extra good" non-prorated road hazard policy.

You could also ask if they have a tire in stock that is "used" with approximately the same amount of tread as your other rear tire. A lot of times they have these when people upsize their wheels and tires on packages. May be a long shot, but doesn't hurt to ask.

Thirdly, I have bought a used tire from ebay in the past. You can probably find your exact tire with the approximate amount of tread for 1/3 to 1/2 the cost of a new tire.
 
@ricrawling - thanks for the suggestions! I do really hate to be spending on a tire this soon after buying the car - three months and 2k miles.

But I am too unskilled to be able to do my own tire install or to understand an eBay tire. :)

I will see if I can get time out to go to yet another tire shop. Been to two - one independent shop and Costco...

As for the tire, I assume you are also saying that I should get the same tires.

Thanks!
 
I would try and stay with the same tire/axle yes. I took my ebay tire up to discount tire, and they mounted/balanced the new tire for about $20.
 
2011 4.6 Genesis. Done about 13K miles. Tires are all in good shape.

My choices are:
1. get a stock factory tire (Dunlop) - comes with standard Dunlop warranty
2. get a tire from Costco (Michelin) - comes with Costco's road hazard warranty

Considering that I am losing the tire due to a road hazard (a screw!!), I am inclined to go with option 2 above. Downside is that I will one odd tire.

Any thoughts?

So the tire you have isn't road-hazard protected? When you purchased you did not opt for the tire/rim warranty?

Buy the same exact OEM tire (preferably from, say, DISCOUNT tire (they will match prices with anybody). The downside is that the road hazard warranty for these expensive tires is probably around $28.
Don't mismatch tires. Not worth it.

When we bought our Genny, I sold my 06 Sonata to the dealer, who subsequently sold it off their lot. I had, just last year, put nice Yokohama tires on the Sonata, and did purchase the road hazard warranty for those 4 tires. Well after I picked up the Genny, I went to Discount Tires, where I do my tire-dealing, and asked them if the warranty on the Yokos on the Sonata was refundable or transferable. They said no, BUT what they DID do was to take the SNs of the tires on my Genny and put it in their system so that I can get my rotation and balancing for FREE, as if I'd bought the tires there. They DID offer to road hazard the tires for me (the Genny tires) but at $28 a tire, and we already have the tire/rim warranty in effect with Zurich when we got the car (at a substantially discounted price as well), I did not cover the tires.

I would, however, STRONGLY urge anybody to get the Zurich warranty because the tires on the Genny are not 'el Cheapo factory OEMs'...they are low rolling resistance tire and can cost $250+ each. So a tire in the sidewall can be an expensive avoidable issue.

If you get a new Genny, and did NOT get the Zurich warranty (or something similar), right after you pick it up you might as well head over to the local Discount Tire or other tire warehouse and see if you can get a road hazard coverage. For about $125 it's cheap insurance on 4 $250+ tires. They may not do it, but if you an existing good customer, they may.. :)
 
Thanks all for the timely suggestions and insights.

I have decided to go with an exact replacement of the Dunlop tire.
Since the other three tires have decent tread (at 13k miles), I figured that I would save some time if I just replaced the one bad tire.

Thanks again for chiming in!
______________________________

Help support this site so it can continue supporting you!
 
Since the Dunlops appear-for most Genesis owners-to be pretty crappy tires- why not just spring for the Michelins?
 
Since the Dunlops appear-for most Genesis owners-to be pretty crappy tires- why not just spring for the Michelins?

I just went with the uniform advice here that I should not mismatch the tires... Since I am only looking at replacing the one tire that has gone bad.

Michelin would indeed have a 40K miles road hazard warranty from Costco for about $25 more than the other local tire shop that I go to. So I was leaning towards Michelin until I heard from people here.

You don't think so?
 
Speaking of replacing tires, we took my wife's G35 coupe to our local Goodyear dealer to have rear snow tires installed. The service manager said that as of this year by federal regulation they can't install snow tires just on the rear - they have to install snows on all four corners. Furthermore, if you have a certain amount of tread wear (don't remember the number) and have to replace a tire you will have to replace two, or possibly all four, tires due to the difference that would result from mixing a new tire with full tread with 3 others with less tread. There are apparently some differences regarding this policy depending on whether the car has AWD, etc. I was not aware of this. The dealer's personal advice was to forget about snow tires altogether and run good all-weather's. I have been dealing with this company for years and they have never steered me wrong, so I don't think they were just handing me a line.
 
Speaking of replacing tires, we took my wife's G35 coupe to our local Goodyear dealer to have rear snow tires installed. The service manager said that as of this year by federal regulation they can't install snow tires just on the rear - they have to install snows on all four corners. Furthermore, if you have a certain amount of tread wear (don't remember the number) and have to replace a tire you will have to replace two, or possibly all four, tires due to the difference that would result from mixing a new tire with full tread with 3 others with less tread. There are apparently some differences regarding this policy depending on whether the car has AWD, etc. I was not aware of this. The dealer's personal advice was to forget about snow tires altogether and run good all-weather's. I have been dealing with this company for years and they have never steered me wrong, so I don't think they were just handing me a line.

mix matching tires is very dangerous - Seems like the G35 is the fun summer car, why drive it in the winter at all? You will have serious understeer with just winter tires on the rear as shown in the video with the BMW not making the turn and heading in the ditch.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzB7hpWhqIA"]Tire Rack Tire Test - Winter Tires: Mixed vs. Matched Tires - YouTube[/ame]
 
Speaking of replacing tires, we took my wife's G35 coupe to our local Goodyear dealer to have rear snow tires installed. The service manager said that as of this year by federal regulation they can't install snow tires just on the rear - they have to install snows on all four corners.

I'd LOVE to know what 'federal regulation he was referring to. Did he tell you this near the end of the month?

I ask because I just had a 'tire issue' with Discount Tire in Lancaster OH a couple of months ago. To make a long story short, we live in SE Arizona. I've dealt with Discount Tire for better than two decades here. Never had a problem. Well, last October we in OH visiting my folks in Canal Winchester. My folks also assist my (step)sister who is disabled and cannot work. Anyways, we had to get my sister's van back on the road and after some front end repairs, I checked the tires closely and they were all 10+ years old and starting to crack. My dad normally does ALL his tire dealing with Sam's Club, but after some discussion I convinced him to try Discount Tire (in Lancaster OH). I got on the computer and did some research for tires, and decided on a set of 4 nice Kelly-Springfield tires for $65 each. I called the Lancaster OH Discount Tire and talked to a nice service guy who said they had the tires in stock and we could get them installed right away if we showed up soon.

We drove about 13 miles to DT, and when we go there, I asked for the rep who I talked to on the phone regarding the 4 tires we wanted to have put on the van. That guy was busy, but the "assistant manager" (maybe he was the manager, I don't remember) said he'd help us. I told him we wanted the four K-S tires. He went out and looked at the van and came back in and immediately attempted to 'upgrade' the tires to a more expensive model (would have cost my 86 yr old dad an extra $150). I said, "No thanks, we would really just like to have the 4 K-S tires installed.." I went on to explain that my folks are paying for the tires, so they don't need the upgrades, and that my sister, who is disabled, doesn't drive that fast or far. He went off into some 'safety spiel' bout how the tires would only be 'adequate' and that they might not be as safe (under "federal regulation", his words, not mine) as the more expensive tires.

I rebuffed him again, smiling, of course, and my dad added "why would you sell tires that are UNSAFE?"...he stammerd a bit and said that while the tires were 'safe', he tried to point out the tires would ride 'bad' and not provide as good traction. I pointed out to him that according to their OWN website, the tires were a 'great value', provide good traction and long life (50,000 mile tread life). The reviews people had were all positive as well. Well, he tried ONE MORE TIME with "Well, please hear me out..." at which point I interruped him, SMILING of course, and said "Look, I did a lot of convincing to get my dad to come here, because I've dealt whth Discount Tire where I live in AZ for over 20 years. DO YOU WANT OUR BUSINESS OR NOT?" Well with that he said "Whatever you want". I said thank you and he said come back in a hour to pick up the VAN.

We went to dinner and came back and the tires were mounted, balanced and done. We started to settle the bill and I guess to add "insult to injury" I said, "Oh by the way, my dad is a WWIII Veteran...do you have a discount?" He looked a bit red-faced as he deducted an additional 10% off the bill. My dad was smiling all the while and we went out and got in that van and drove it back to parents' home and those tires are GREAT. My sister had been driving on them since then and she has no complaints either.

Moral of the story: Even with a place you trust, BEWARE. Especially near the end of the month (they do EVERYTHING to BOOST sales or revenue).

So anyways, sorry for the long story - again, I'd like to know what 'federal regulation' was being referenced to get you to put two additional tires on your car.... ;)
 
Re: what is the best tire to replace the rear passenger tire - tire has screw in the

My car got hit and I lost a tire/wheel. I took the opportunity to replace all 4 of the dunflops.
 
My car got hit and I lost a tire/wheel. I took the opportunity to replace all 4 of the dunflops.

hmm. i guess i am going in for another Dunflop.
but too late to change anything now - they ordered the tire and it has arrived at the local place where i typically go.
 
I would try and stay with the same tire/axle yes. I took my ebay tire up to discount tire, and they mounted/balanced the new tire for about $20.


I have never bought a tire from Costco or some of the other places that are mentioned, but I have bought every tire I have needed since 1981 at Discount Tire and have always been very happy with service and price. On 5 different times I have taken a car into them with a low tire and they fixed a flat for no charge. On 2 of those times, they were original equipment tires that they had not sold me. I may have just been lucky, but I have always found them to have great service and I've gotten to where that means a lot to me.

Just my 2 cents worth.
 
I'd LOVE to know what 'federal regulation he was referring to. Did he tell you this near the end of the month?

Moral of the story: Even with a place you trust, BEWARE. Especially near the end of the month (they do EVERYTHING to BOOST sales or revenue).

So anyways, sorry for the long story - again, I'd like to know what 'federal regulation' was being referenced to get you to put two additional tires on your car.... ;)

C'mon - I was born at night, but not last night. This was not a sales pitch: the dealer made no attempt whatever to sell us new tires and in fact discouraged us from buying them. He said the rules were nuts and he would not buy new tires himself if he were in our shoes. He did say that there had been a number of successful lawsuits nationwide against dealers who mixed new and old tires resulting in accidents, and that the dealers in questioned received huge fines. As a result, his management recently put all of their stores on notice that - as company policy, posted prominently in their stores - they would not mix new/vs old and/or snow vs. non-snow tires. He did say that there were undoubtedly plenty of gas stations that would install any tire(s) you might want. This is a big Goodyear dealer with lots of locations in my area.
 
I just went with the uniform advice here that I should not mismatch the tires... Since I am only looking at replacing the one tire that has gone bad.

Michelin would indeed have a 40K miles road hazard warranty from Costco for about $25 more than the other local tire shop that I go to. So I was leaning towards Michelin until I heard from people here.

You don't think so?

I guess I was a bit cloudy. LOL. My thought was to ditch all four Dunlops for a new SET of Michelins.
 
Back
Top