• Car enthusiast? Join us on Cars Connected! iOS | Android | Desktop
  • Hint: Use a descriptive title for your new message
    If you're looking for help and want to draw people in who can assist you, use a descriptive subject title when posting your message. In other words, "I need help with my car" could be about anything and can easily be overlooked by people who can help. However, "I need help with my transmission" will draw interest from people who can help with a transmission specific issue. Be as descriptive as you can. Please also post in the appropriate forum. The "Lounge" is for introducing yourself. If you need help with your G70, please post in the G70 section - and so on... This message can be closed by clicking the X in the top right corner.

Can the Genesis Prestige Really (really) Compete?

Status
Not open for further replies.
JD Powers and reliable info do not belong in the same sentence. Common sense tells you that no one can determine quality and reliability in 90 days of ownership :rolleyes:

The trolling stops when you take the initiative and SERIOUSLY research into JD Powers value of info. When you don't hear much of them in the car enthusiasts magz, forums, edmunds, etc.; that should give you a clue.
 
We're doing a pretty good job keeping things civil - and let's keep it that way..

So let's say Hyundai does bring this car to the United States under a new brand name - Genesis - and the model name is "Prestige"... What kinds of things do you think will be below par or missing in comparison to the S-Class, 7-Series and LS?
 
Before trolling you might want to spend 30 seconds on Google to see if your points are easily destroyed. Just for starters here's the 2008 JD Powers initial quality survey which lists Mercedes as #4 (far from the worst as you claim): http://www.jdpower.com/autos/rating...rand/sortcolumn-1/ascending/page-#page-anchor. Incidentally Hyundai is #13.

And you may want to learn the difference between reliability/dependability and initial quality. Initial quality means nothing in the overall scheme of things IMO. Granted, MB has made a big leap from where they were 3 years ago, they're still slightly below average and several spots below Hyundai.

http://www.jdpower.com/corporate/news/releases/pressrelease.aspx?ID=2009043
 
No offense to all of you. But, who gives a flying fig about the rich. The wealthy will keep their Rolls Royces, Bentleys and alike and that is fine. I think that Hyundai is trying to give us non-wealthy a chance to drive a good looking car (Genesis owner and EXTREMELLY HAPPY) for an almost bargain price, equipped quite nicely thank you.

Previous to owning two BMW 5 series (2003-525i & 2006 530I) I would have NEVER thought if going for a Hyundai, but, when I saw the Genesis and saw that I could be driving a car with LOTS more equipment for a hell of alot less money (anf of course after driving it) the choice was simple.
:)
As per the Equus, I personally think is ABSOLTELY GORGEOUS and - if I could afforded - would get one in a second! The interior is very classy and outside is quite nice.

I do agree 100% (because I've brought it before) is that Hyundai needs to open separate dealers for the Genesis brand (sedan, coupe & Equus if they bring it to the U.S.).

Personally, I don't want to walk in to a Hyundai dealer and walk out with a $40,000 (V6) or $50 something (Equus) car.

So, let the wealthy have their cars and let Hyundai make near luxury cars for an almost bargain price! That is quite fine by me.

Flex59
 
Before trolling you might want to spend 30 seconds on Google to see if your points are easily destroyed. Just for starters here's the 2008 JD Powers initial quality survey which lists Mercedes as #4 (far from the worst as you claim): http://www.jdpower.com/autos/rating...rand/sortcolumn-1/ascending/page-#page-anchor. Incidentally Hyundai is #13.


im going to nickname you pick and pull because in the sedan area you said the prices you gave was based off the utmost reliable source(consumer rpts) but here you pull your other trump card lol (jd powers). you make me laugh, consumer reports 2009 does not recommend one single benz due to its poor reliability. 90,000 dollar cars that cant surpass hyundai in reliabilty...the mercedes dealers would love to have you. muah...later. and only reason why hyundai is #13 because of azera and entourage which is going away anyway.
 
i tell you guys the funniest thing, just sold a champagne beige tech 3.8 an hr ago to a customer who has an 745li 05 to his parents and guess what his lady has an slk benz and wants to trade it so we let him take home for the night a satin white pearl/ cashmere 4.6 tech. o i forgot those type of customers would never be interested in a genesis..dang, they also payed straight CASH..no finance. $40,117.69 OTD.
 
The Genesis and the Prestige will be competing for the same customers. The people who buy the big name luxury cars for the status will not even consider a Hyundai no matter how good it is. Hyundai dealers cannot handle the Genesis customers properly they sure can't handle an even more up market car customer. I think Hyundai is about to shoot its self in the foot.

Thank God you don't run Hyundai (or any other auto manufacturer).


Do you think the people who are in the upper class care about more pockets or leather over brand name? The Benz, BMW, and Lexus would surely be the car of choice for the rich.

Are you really this obtuse?

How many times does it have to be said that if Hyundai does bring the Equus over to the States, that it will be under a new "prestige" brand?

And many people in the upper class (not the brand wh*res who know little about what they buy) do their due diligence before they buy and buy mostly on quality of the product and price per performance ratio - which is why Lexus, a "no-name" brand a couple of decades ago became so successful.

To rich people its not whether the car performs the best, although all of the expensive cars listed above do perform far better than the Genesis, and I'm sure will perform better than the Equus, its whether the car can take you to your destination in the most classy way possible.

You're basing this on what?

Hyundai is in no means like Benz or BMW. Those two are top of the line imports. BMW used to make airplanes, check me on that, and Mercedes came to life as one of the first cars in 1886, and has had decades of racing experience. Both of these car companies started out geared toward the rich.

Uhh, BMW during the 60s and 70s was hardly considered catering to the rich. It was only during the 1980s did it start being the "yuppie" vehicle of choice and even then, it wasn't considered a true luxury marque like Mercedes.

Hyundai is quite the contrary, started in 1967 Hyundai is not all that old, or experienced. Toyota on the other hand started in the 1930s and has become the world's largest auto producer with exceptional quality and service.

Wow - a 3 decade difference! Big whoop.

Mazda otoh, was founded in 1920 - gee, I guess that must mean that Mazda must be a powerhouse in the auto industry and clearly better than Toyota since it predates Toyo by 17 yrs.

And Suzuki even more so since it predate Toyo by nearly 3 decades (about the same as Toyo predates Hyundai).

To me it seems that Hyundai has a long way to go. Their first genesis coupe accident resulted in a tragedy when the airbags didn't deploy, and just look at the genesis airbag recall now. Hyundai doesnt seem to have the experience nor the service capabilities to be able to produce such high quality cars. Honda tried to create a luxury line with acura, and that didn't turn out to well.

1st of that was a pre-production model and the driver wasn't wearing his seatbelt.

2nd, there have been no other such incidences.

3rd, I guess Toyota has a "long way to go" as well since since the airbags didn't inflate when Eric Stromer, one of the hosts of Top Gear USA, flipped and crashed his Camry.

You have to be all in when you decide to create a luxury line. You cant sell a $16,000 car in the same room as a $100,000 because lets face it, the rich don't want the same door knob or door screw as the poor. Toyota has done an incredible job separating Lexus from itself. My family has 2 Lexuses and you dont see one little symbol for Toyota. Acura had that problem, where the windows had Honda on them.

God - you know jack about the auto industry.

Again, Hyundai would only bring over the Equus under a new prestige brand due to the peculiarities of the US market.

But Mercede-Benz in Europe (and elsewhere) sells the econobox A and B Class alongside the $100K S Class (MB does sell the B Class in Canada).

Until a few years ago, Lexus models were all sold as Toyotas (the LS was known as the Toyota Celsior) in Japan and Infinitis and Acuras continue to be sold as Nissans and Hondas.

Furthermore, a no. of Toyota models continue to be just as luxurious, if not more so than the top Lexus models.

The Toyota Century is a limo class auto and the special edition Toyota Century Royal is used by the top members of the Japanese royal family (yeah, they ride in a "lowly" Toyota; prior to that, the royal family rode in a Nissan).

The Toyota Crown Majesta is considered to be an S-Class fighter in Japan and is classed higher than the Celsior/LS.

There are 5 things they should do:

- Make a designated dealership
- Combat Mercedes, BMW, and Lexus directly in ALL fields
- Build better performing, more comfortable, and better looking cars (the Genesis looks way to generic)
- CHANGE THE NAME!!!
- and slow down the pace or do something extremely extraordinary

Sorry - but the LAST THING Hyundai should do is to take any "advice" from you.

And oh, there was nothing more generic-looking than the LS430 (well, maybe the entire run of the ES) - which, btw, was a blatant rip-off of the S Class.


the genesis coupe can barely compete with a nissan 370z, let alone an infiniti.

Uhh, the Genesis Coupe is not a luxury coupe.

And it competes very well w/ the G37, thank you (bettering it on the track).

what im saying is that hyundai is calling everything that they are taking out a genesis. The genesis sedan would do fine in a luxury dealership with suspension fixes and less recalls, but the coupe is a joke for luxury.

Again, the Genesis Coupe is not a "luxury coupe" - and what was a joke for "luxury" was the interior of the Infiniti G35 for the first few years.


Also their styl eis stolen from other cars.

Funny - that's what they said and still say about Toyota/Lexus.

And whats up with the new emblem on the equus, do they plan on confusing everyone so that they will buy a hyundai without realizing it. All BMWs, Benzs, and Lexuss have one emblem for all of their cars. Hyundai is just confusing everyone with their emblems. But then again they were to ashamed to put their flying H on their flagship genesis.

Uhh, that "emblem" has been on the previous gen Equus and it's not something one wouldn't also see in Japanese limo-class models.

And oh, Hyundai wasn't ashaed to put the flying H on the Genesis, they gave the public the choice of 2 grilles, one w/ and one w/o and just did what the consumer wanted.


Lets put this in terms of apparel. Think about it as hyundai's Genesis line as being a $50 purse that you can buy at a Marshall's. Now think of Mercedes as a Luis Vuitton, BMW as a Channel, and Lexus as a Gucci. Suppose the $50 purse has far more leather and a lot more pockets than all of the others.

An incorrect and rather stupid analogy (shocking!).

First off, Hyundai in no way considers itself a competitor to Mercedes, etc. in the US (until it launches a prestige brand).

Second, what was the ES, which for a large part of its history, was a mishmash of Toyota parts - Camry, Vista, Windom, etc. as well as the the LX, which is basically a re-badged Land Cruiser?

Third, a better analogy would be Hyundai being like the leathermaker, Coach, moving its product-line gradually upscale over the years - but launching a new "ultra-luxury" to compete w/ Prada, Chanel, Bottega Venetta, etc.

Fourth, the CEO of Toyota considers Hyundai to be their biggest threat (I think he has a much better idea about this than you do - who basically doesn't know much about the auto industry).
 
Last edited:
YEH, you are as dumb as a rock but since you actually believe you know it all you will never be able to comprehend why somebody would think such a thing. Some of your statements make sense but most are completely wrong. A new Prestige brand, huh.......I won't even go there. I'll let some of the other fine members you insulted give their opinions of your post.
 
Last edited:
I think there are some things not understood in this discussion:

1. Hyundai may be considering a new brand called Genesis, and the the Prestige would fall under that brand. Hyundai was soliciting advice about what to call the Equus in the US just a few weeks ago, so maybe they have decided to call it the Prestige. The branding issue (Hyundai vs Genesis) is separate from the Equus/Prestige issue (could be the Genesis Prestige or Hyundai Prestige).

2. It is not economically feasible to open new dealerships in the US for a Genesis brand if they decide create a separate brand. The price of the Genesis is a big factor in its success, and opening new dealerships would raise dealer costs, and therefor prices, significantly. It is hard enough for existing Hyundai dealers to stay in business in this economy (not to mention dealers for other brands), so it would not be possible to find enough people to invest in new dealerships at this time. No bank in the US would approve the construction loans. This idea is out of the question at the current time. Both Lexus and Acura have a significantly larger selection of vehicles (8 for Lexus, 5 for Acura) than would a Genesis line have right now. It would take years just open the new dealerships.

3. The Genesis Sedan, Coupe, and Equus are currently sold in Korea and other export markets outside of North America. At this time, the US market has potential, but Hyundai does not have to sell large numbers of Genesis, Prestige, etc models in North America to keep these lines going. In Korea, the Genesis sedan and Equus don't have Hyundai badging. The Genesis Coupe is badged as a Hyundai in Korea from what I have seen. Not sure how dealerships work in Korea.

4. It is rather obvious that some people in the US are very brand sensitive in the upscale or luxury car market, and will not buy a Hyundai product for that reason, no matter how good or affordable it is. But there are quite a few current and former owners of well-known and prestigious upscale/luxury brands who will (and have) bought the Genesis. Market research has shown that people who have already done the prestigious thing before, are actually more likely to buy a Genesis than people who are buying their first upscale/luxury car. Anyway, there are enough potential buyers to go around for the Genesis to be a success, especially if the price is right.

5. I seriously doubt that Hyundai expects to sell a lot of Equus/Prestige models in the US. It is not important that they do so. One of HMA main goals right now is to build the Hyundai image, and showing people what Hyundai can do if they want to is important in that regard. That is why the Equus was built in Korea in the first place. All they have to do is make some minor changes and ship it over to the US. It is sort of like racing--people do think more highly of a brand involved in racing, even though the model they end up buying is not anything like the race car. People buy C Class Mercedes because it is a prestigious brand, not because the C Class is a luxury car.

6. The overall success of Hyundai in North America does not now, nor will it ever, depend on the Genesis or the Equus/Prestige. It will depend on the Sonata, Elantra, and maybe SUV/Crossover vehicles depending on future energy prices. The Genesis/Prestige will do nicely in a niche market, but they primarily improve the Hyundai image so they can sell the other cars in volume.
 
Guys. I've done a little editing in this discussion. Name calling is against the rules here. Please don't allow emotions to run your show. Attack ideas, not people. Please.
 
I would expect some disagreement here, after all, this is a HYUNDAI forum. I don't know whether you guys are trying to lie to yourselves in order to feel better, but hyundai will not become the next Mercedes Benz, or BMW. If you tell someone you bought a $70,000 hyundai, they'll laugh in your face, hell I would! I'm 18, have a high income family, and have a $48,000 budget for my first car. I definitely considered the Genesis (that's why I'm on this forum). But after realizing how generic the Genesis is, and how embarrassed I'd be when my friends asked me what I drove, I have decided to go for an alternative. I am going to buy a Camaro 2SS, something that is proud of its heritage and has emblems already on it. As for the few of you who are degrading my comments, I totally understand. This is a Hyundai Genesis forum. You guys are trying to protect what you love and care for, but to think that hyundai will be able to compete with German imports like Mercedes and BMW, you are dead wrong. I respect many people on this forum, but also realize that there are many ignorant people who try to lie to themselves thinking that they drive a Mercedes, even though they cant afford one. Open your eyes! Your car is a HYUNDAI! not a Mercedes. As for the prestige, it looks good, its not very original, but it looks good. Th lights were stolen off the new S class, and the rear looks like the LS460's ( look at the images posted on this thread). The emblem is completely different from hyundai's (because they are too embarrassed to show that it's a hyundai). Most of you who own the Genesis took off the emblems because you didn't like the hyundai emblem. It degraded the status of the car. You can say that you liked the other OEM emblem more, but the new emblems bear no meaning. No other car has that emblem, rendering the manufacturer anonymous. When you see other BMW's driving by, you don't see a different emblem, same goes for the Mercedes'. And I love how someone on this forum compared the Genesis Coupe's airbag malfunction to a Toyota Camry's malfunction (TIP- if you want to show that the Genesis brand line is catering to the rich don't compare it to a Toyota Camry;)). I am in no means trying to tell you that hyundai is a bad brand, all I am saying is that they have a hell of a long way to go, but they started on the right foot with the Genesis. However, I believe that the Luxury brands that exist today will kill out Hyundai's dreams of becoming a luxury brand manufacturer, just like they did for Acura and Infiniti. And plus hyundai is throwing designs out without even fixing critical problems (airbag recalls, suspension issues,...). I would like to say good riddance, but I think it will have to wait, I still would like to respond to comments. As for my 6.2L V8 beast of a Camaro, I put one in order, and it will come in 3 months. I'm counting everyday that goes by.:rolleyes:

I don't want to sound cocky, but I would consider myself rich. My family has 5 cars, 2 lexus, 2 mercedes, and a Hummer H1. When I told my parents i wanted a Hyundai, they started laughing. I was somewhat embarrassed, thinking that I made a bad choice, but after a while they opened up to it and decided to let me test drive one. the car was a 4.6 tech, and my dad liked it. However realizing the unprofessional and run down hyundai dealerships, we realized that it would be a stupid choice. Later on, i thought about how I'd feel when i told my friends (also from wealthy families) what i drove. They are all going to get sporty BMWs and Mercedess, while I drive in with a car that know one has ever seen with an emblem that is just as unknown. However, this did not bug me. I could throw in the value factor if they thought i was stupid. But then I thought, what value? You could get a fully loaded Infiniti G37, something that is not as generic for the same price. The value that you all talk about completely mystifies me. I think why most people bought this car is because it LOOKS like a Mercedes with BMW tail lights, and a Lexus like Map layout and an iDrive controller. Nothing else. Wow they threw in a sun shade (which all luxury cars have), and 2 extra speakers. My sister's Lexus IS has 14 speakers. Holy Shit, like you need 17. Hyundai just did that so that they could beat BMW in one category: Number of Speakers (since the cost of speakers is so cheap).

Anyway, say what you have to say, I like reading the responses. Call me what you want. This is one of the only threads that puts the Genesis line down. All the other threads everyone agrees to the same thing. If you really like your car, then you don't give a shit what i say (which is awesome, you should love what you drive). I am just that way, I cant wait for my Camaro. I dont care at all what you say about GM. If the CEO was George Bush himself, I'd laugh and say that he has good taste, and I'd still by the car.
 
Last edited:
i tell you guys the funniest thing, just sold a champagne beige tech 3.8 an hr ago to a customer who has an 745li 05 to his parents and guess what his lady has an slk benz and wants to trade it so we let him take home for the night a satin white pearl/ cashmere 4.6 tech. o i forgot those type of customers would never be interested in a genesis..dang, they also payed straight CASH..no finance. $40,117.69 OTD.

Just wait till they return complaining about the suspension.
 
Kinetics, you raise some valid points. Hyundai is not going to compete head-to-head with BMW and Mercedes. The price point of the Genesis pretty much dictates that. Not many people who can easily afford a Merc S class are going to buy a Genesis 4.6 even if they are about the same size. I don't think anyone is saying they will, nor is that Hyundai's goal. Hyundai is primarily a economy car manufacturer and they live or die by the Sonata and Elantra in the US.

But the Genesis is pretty good car for the money. It was developed in Korea for the Korean market. It doesn't cost anywhere near $48,000, so perhaps you were looking at the wrong cars to begin with. Now if you weren't rich and the $48,000 was your hard-earned money, you just might consider buying a Genesis and spending the money you saved on some other things. But if money for the other things is not an issue, then I can see that the bargain price of the Genesis is not important to you.

You are correct that there a lot of people who are very prestige conscious, and cars are often a big part of that. If all your friends and your family's friends drive well-known luxury brands, then maybe you would want to do the same if you can easily afford it. But there are a lot of other people in this world whose friends don't drive luxury cars (none of mine do), and there are a lot of other people who "used to care" what other people think, but don't care any more about the superficial things in life. There are plenty of both these types of people around who will buy the Genesis.

Warren Buffet, one if the richest people on the planet, drives a Cadillac DTS. He lives in the same house in the central Omaha Nebraska that he bought in 1958 for $31,500, and is today valued at around $700,000 (at least it was before the real estate crash).

With regard to the Equus/Prestige, that car was developed in Korea as sort of concept car to show what Hyundai could do if cost was no object. Hyundai has a captive market in Korea so they can sell some of those cars there, for pretty much the same reason that the US President rides around in a custom made Caddy instead of a custom made Benz. If they bring it to the US, it will be just to show people what Hyundai can do, and not to compete with BMW and Mercedes. They will put it in the showroom, and people will get in the back seat and get a massage (built-in to the seats), and then feel much better about buying that Sonata instead of the Camry or Accord, or maybe buying a Genesis instead of a ES350.

But one other thing. You are only 18 and don't really know much about the history of cars in the US. When I was 18, Toyota only had Corollas in the US. and they were very small, cheap, underpowered cars that were not very popular. Over the years, the quality of the cars improved, and they slowly added more upscale cars like the Camry, and then eventually launched Lexus. The process of developing the Lexus brand took many years to get to where Lexus is today. Hyundai is just now starting out with the Genesis, and who knows what will happen in 20 years. Business people in Asia are very patient. A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.
 
Looking to update and upgrade your Genesis luxury sport automobile? Look no further than right here in our own forum store - where orders are shipped immediately!
Thanks for your reply Mark, I agree completely. All that I'm saying is that hyundai will get maybe as far as infiniti, which also offers value and luxury. Also, it seems to me that hyundai is trying to compete with Mercedes and BMW, the genesis websites shows videos of the Genesis competing against the two brands in many fields, and just look at their superbowl commercial. Anyway thank you for your reply.
 
funny she wants to get rid of her benz because of issue after issue and cost of repair.
 
. If you tell someone you bought a $70,000 hyundai, they'll laugh in your face, hell I would! I'm 18, have a high income family, and have a $48,000 budget for my first car. I definitely considered the Genesis (that's why I'm on this forum). But after realizing how generic the Genesis is, and how embarrassed I'd be when my friends asked me what I drove, I have decided to go for an alternative!

Well it's people like you who have turned this country into the laughing stock of the world. No wonder other countries consider the US a collection of elitist, arrogant, self-centered snobs.


I am going to buy a Camaro 2SS, something that is proud of its heritage and has emblems already on it.
Buddy, have you noticed that foreign cars - and Hyundai BTW - are actually better built cars that most domestics? Good luck driving a car that will most likely be visiting the shop on a more frequent basis than my Genesis.

As for the few of you who are degrading my comments, I totally understand.
Admission of being a snob unfortunately won't change who you really are.
Open your eyes! Your car is a HYUNDAI! not a Mercedes.
And I'll be using the money saved to send my kids to school.
Most of you who own the Genesis took off the emblems because you didn't like the hyundai emblem. It degraded the status of the car.
Wrong again buddy. We did it because it looks better than the H emblem. But you know us better than we do, so I guess you're right.
I don't want to sound cocky.
Too late
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your reply Mark, I agree completely. All that I'm saying is that hyundai will get maybe as far as infiniti, which also offers value and luxury. Also, it seems to me that hyundai is trying to compete with Mercedes and BMW, the genesis websites shows videos of the Genesis competing against the two brands in many fields, and just look at their superbowl commercial. Anyway thank you for your reply.
Not sure what you are referring to. The Hyundai website offers a comparison feature run by a third party company that many manufacturer websites have. The suggested comparisons are:

- 2009 Cadillac CTS 3.6L SFI
- 2009 Chrysler 300 C HEMI RWD
- 2009 Lexus ES 350
- 2009 Pontiac G8 Sedan

I don't think those are out of line to compare against the Hyundai Genesis, and I don't see BMW or Mercedes in this list.

The Super Bowl made fun of the Japanese and German competition without being specific. Certainly the Genesis stacks up very well against the Merc C Class, and Lexus ES 350, especially since it is significantly larger than either of these two. But again, look the list above that Hyundai is suggesting that Genesis owners may also be considering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top