In a nutshell, you went from an 18"
wheel to a 19"
wheel. You would have to do the calculations to see what percentage your odometer and fuel consumption calculations would be off. A 1" difference in
rim diameter
rim will result in a larger circumference at the tire surface (the tire has to be included as well).
So in a 'mile' the tires will make less rotations than a stock tire to cover that mile, and the displayed MPH will be off as the computer has not been reprogrammed to know the right size of tire. So your actual speed will be a bit more than what is displayed on the speedometer. And your fuel economy calculations will be off by the same amount that your speedometer is off (for the good, you'll show that you are getting better fuel economy)
BUT.......
Having said that, it would appear that your choice of tires and
rims has more than offset the (fake) fuel economy caused by the larger-sized tires. Fuel consumption increases when you increase weight because it takes MORE fuel to accelerate the extra weight to speed. And in turn, you use more brake pad each time to slow down the extra weight.
SO, larger
rims, and larger tires = more weight. I would have inquired about this before I took the step to install larger tires and wheels, as it is something I would take under consideration before I bought them.
And another big thing to consider is the
ROLLING RESISTANCE of the tires you've chosen. Takes more fuel to push them down the road.
So in short, the larger
rims/tires would have caused a slightly better perceived fuel economy, but the combined weight of
rims and tires, and the wider tires with increased rolling resistance, have negated the perceived increase. So if you do the calculations properly, you may find that the fuel loss is a bit more than you actually see.
Of course, why complain about the fuel economy in a $50K car? LoL....
Now, I know that if I by my tires at Discount Tire, I can drive on them for 30 days and exchange them for something less fuel consuming. I think other tire shops have similar policies, but I don't know for sure.