luck11
2023 GV70 2.5T Prestige
Well, they are an all-season tire. Any all-season tire is a compromise tire and generally do only okay, at best, in winter conditions. Simply the nature of the tread and the rubber compound used (winter tires have softer rubber to remain pliable and grip better in really cold temps). So all depends where you live and needs are. Where I live, I would not drive without a winter tire, and always have dedicated set of winter tires and wheels, and another set of wheels and tires for summer.I picked up my car just 4 days ago and have been hearing everyone say how bad the Michelin primacy’s are for snow&ice.
What are they good for then? Not even a week since I took procession and i’m already looking for set of winter tires that fits.
Should I hold onto the primacy for next spring &summer, or should I sell them?
In terms of holding onto the Primacy's, tough to answer. If you plan on maintaining the same wheel size, or using the stock wheel, then why not keep them for spring summer fall? The Primacy Tour A/S gets pretty good reviews. However, I would advise against swapping out tires on same wheel each season as that negatively impacts the tire and stretches the bead. You can probably do a bit more research on this though as I do no profess to be an expert. If so, then consider a 2nd set of dedicated wheels, either for winter or summer, use your stock wheels for one or the other, depending on which wheel you deem to be the "nicer" wheel, ie. generally use the more aesthetically pleasing wheel in summer).
I am not a fan of the stock 19" wheels. Not bad, but meh... Also, I am not a fan of the proportion of wheel to rubber...too much sidewall. I am finicky about that, and I can just look at it and see what a good proportion is for my tastes, 21" and stock size being perfect frankly. But like @dhuhtala mentioned, going with a bigger wheel, means a shorter side wall if you're going to keep same overall diameter, and that comes at the expense of ride quality. Important consideration that comes down to personal circumstances and preferences.