I find both Bogey99's post and Warren's reply interesting.
Bogey states that despite a very positive BMW 5 series experience,
he will at least consider the Genesis G80.
Warren observes that he thinks Bogey will stay with BMW, despite the fact that Warrren, having owned Lexus LS,
actually purchased an Equus.
In my case, the switch to Hyundai/Genesis was from Infinity. I went from a G35 to a Sonata.. (a deliberate downshift), and then from the Sonata to an Azera. My other strongest consideration at the time was ES.
Prior to the Genesis, I also considered CTS, and GS and ES. I found the Genesis to be the better value.
My take - Genesis will get SOME consideration from current top tier LUX brands, and will also likely get even more consideration from the more size or more features, etc. driven customer.
Looking back at history, Lexus owed a lot of their early growth from conquests from
Cadillac,
Lincoln, etc. It wasn't just grabbing S Class and 7 Series buyers out of the gate. What is Lexus' best seller? ES, not LS. "Luxury", but at a much more affordable price.
G80 will likely pull much of it's volume from people who move from ES, or Q50, and perhaps CTS and MKZ to some degree. They will also get a bit of volume from 5 Series, A6 and E Class prospects and owners. Reading through the "previously owned" threads on this forum shows this to be true.
Regarding pricing, yes there have been some incredibly deep discounts on the current Genesis. If I had waited 30 days, I could have saved about $2-3K, and probably around $4-5K now. Hyundai probably would have been better served by driving some better deals early on. Instead they let inventory build, and held some desirable color and feature combinations at port last summer and early fall.
Rome was not built in a day. They will likely increase brand value over time, and grow vs. the competition over time as well.